Page 111

“Was the sale compulsory?”

“Not on paper,” Charlotte answers.

“That is part of the difficulty. My great-grandfather technically signed the transaction.”

I understand immediately.

“But the circumstances surrounding the signature are the issue,” I say.

“Exactly,” she replies.

“The family was Jewish. Their businesses were under pressure, accounts had become difficult to access, and they were attempting to secure permission and funds to leave Germany. The painting was sold for considerably less than its established value.”

I nod slowly.

“That gives us a forced-sale question even if the transaction itself was documented as voluntary.”

“That is my understanding.”

“It doesn’t automatically invalidate every later transfer,” I say. “We’d need to separate the historical circumstances from the current title and trace what happened to the painting afterward.”

Charlotte slides another page toward me. “That part is unusually well documented.”

I scan the chronology. The painting moved through several private collections after the war, crossed into Switzerland, changed hands again in the early sixties and eventually entered a major British collection before its final private transfer decades later.

My eyes reach the last name.

I stop.

Kensington Family Collection.

For a moment, I hear nothing from the hallway outside my office.

I force myself to keep reading.

The date of acquisition is long before my involvement with the family, and nothing in the file suggests impropriety on their side. The painting passed through enough documented transactions that whoever approved the Kensington purchase would have had no obvious reason to question title at the time.

“The Kensingtons acquired it in good faith,” I say.

“Yes,” Charlotte replies. “I want to be very clear about that.”

I look up.

“I’m not interested in accusing the current owners of participating in what happened to my family,” she continues. “They didn’t. I’m also not interested in litigation if it can be avoided.”

“What are you interested in?”

“Bringing the painting home.”

There is no drama in the way she says it. That makes the answer more effective.

I glance back at the photograph.

“Through purchase?”

“Yes.”

“A private treaty transaction?”