Page 14

Then, as quickly as it had arrived, the laugh died in his throat.

Ben’s entire posture went rigid. His smile collapsed, his jaw clenching tight. His eyes widened with a devastating wave of panic that came without warning, as if he’d committed an unforgivable betrayal simply by enjoying a fleeting moment of humor in the town square.

The dark shadow of immediate guilt settled over his face like a physical weight, draining the color from his skin. He pushed his hand back into his coat pocket, his shoulders locking tight as he looked away toward the harbor’s dark waters.

Maggie knew that exact feeling. She recognized it with a cutting, painful clarity that sliced straight through her chest. She remembered the first time she’d laughed at a joke on the bakery porch six months after Tom died. She remembered the sickening wave of guilt that had followed instantly, the cold voice inside her head asking how she could dare to feel joy when the person she loved was lying in the cold earth.

Maggie didn’t turn away from Ben, nor did she pretend she hadn’t seen the sudden, agonizing shift in his eyes. She stepped an inch closer, her voice dropping into a quiet, compassionate tone without judgment.

“Laughter doesn’t mean you’ve forgotten,” Maggie said, her eyes meeting his strained gaze with absolute honesty. “And it doesn’t mean you love her any less.”

Ben swallowed hard, his throat working as he stared at the brick pavers beneath his boots. “It feels like stepping across a line I shouldn’t cross.” His voice came out low and rough, barely louder than the harbor wind.

“I know,” Maggie replied, her thumb rotating the gold band on her finger. “For a long time, I thought that if I let myself laugh, or if I enjoyed a sunny afternoon in the square, I was somehow wiping away Tom’s memory. But grief isn’t a debt we pay by staying in the dark forever. Loving someone who’s gone doesn’t mean we have to stop living.”

Ben looked up slowly, his eyes locking onto hers. The raw vulnerability in his expression was exposed and undeniable, but in Maggie’s gentle, steady gaze, she hoped he found no pity or pressure. Only a shared understanding from someone who had walked through the exact same valley and survived.

Over near the chapel steps, Theo called out, holding his craft star up to show Eli’s grandmother, Susan. His bright, cheerful voice echoed across the square, a sweet reminder of the living world waiting for them.

Ben drew a long, deep breath of the cold, salty air, his shoulders relaxing an inch as he looked over at his grandson. “He really is having a good day,” he murmured.

“He is,” Maggie agreed, offering a warm smile as the evening star appeared in the dusky purple sky above Cranberry Harbor. “And it’s okay for you to have one too.”

MAGGIE

The next evening, Maggie went back to Vivian’s house to check in on her friend, an extra pep in her step after her pleasant Saturday with Ben and Theo. Carol, Diane, and Susan were already there, and Diane handed her a steaming mug of coffee as she walked in and greeted everyone.

Maggie sat in one of the armchairs across from Vivian and set her coffee cup down on the side table. Her eyes lingered on the iron-bound cherry box still resting between them, and even though she still felt immense pressure for her part in spreading Christmas magic, a tender smile tugged at her lips.

Outside the double-hung windows, the night had settled deep over the harbor, the wind whining around the corner eaves. The wood stove in the corner crackled, throwing a warm orange light across the braided area rug.

Diane took a seat and peered over at Vivian as she tapped her pen against her chin, her sharp mind working through the situation. “So, our resident miracle worker, who exactly wrote that first letter to Santa forty years ago? Do we know them?”

Vivian lifted her chin, her gaze locking onto Diane’s with a firm, absolute clarity that admitted no argument. “That’s something the archive box doesn’t tell. The first rule of the blue pouch isn’t written in a book. It’s kept right here.” She pressed a finger against the side of her head. “A secret stays a secret, even after years and years have passed.”

“Not even to us?” Carol asked, her arms crossed over her coat. “We’re the ones taking over the work while you heal. If there’s history tied to these families that we’re mingling our lives with, we ought to know what we’re stepping into.”

“You’re stepping into people’s private lives,” Vivian said, her tone hardening just enough to command full obedience. “You aren’t committee chairs when you open those letters. You aren’t town officials or tax assessors. You’re simply neighbors offering a hand in the dark. The moment you start digging for who wrote what or why they wrote it so long ago, you break the trust that holds this whole tradition together.”

Maggie touched the white envelope that she kept close in her coat pocket containing Theo Foster’s letter. Her thumb traced the folded edge of the paper through the envelope.

Vivian was right, of course. The magic of the private wishes lay in their anonymous dignity. Nobody was asked to explain themselves, nobody was forced to feel like a charity case, and nobody had to thank a town council. Maggie didn’t want Ben thanking her for simply showing up in his life.

“Can you tell us if more letters came that first year?” Maggie asked, breaking the silence that had settled in over the warm room. She didn’t have to know all of the personal details, but nobody could blame her or the other women for being incredibly curious.

“Three before Christmas Eve,” Vivian said, her posture relaxing. “A man whose roof was leaking over his winter woodpile. A young mother who couldn’t afford boots for her toddler. And a boy who wanted his grandfather to come out to the front porch again.”

Maggie’s breath hitched slightly in her throat. Her mind leaped instantly to Theo’s letter. History was repeating itself in Cranberry Cove, forty years later, with a new generation of grieving people hiding away behind closed doors. It was both a sad and comforting truth.

“So, you picked up the blue pouch every week after that first letter came,” Susan said. Her eyes glistened with stark admiration for their secretive matriarch.

“At first, I simply checked the post office box weekly where the first letter was mailed. The next year is when I made a deal with the postman and began picking up the envelope one evening a week throughout the holiday season,” Vivian confirmed. “Over the years since I got started, the town grew, the summer cottages turned into year-round homes, the old hardware store changed hands, but the letters kept coming. Because no matter how prosperous a seaside town looks from the harbor deck, people still get lonely, people still lose the ones they love, and people still need to know that somebody cares whether or not they wake up with a heavy heart on Christmas morning.”

A floorboard creaked in the back hallway near the kitchen door, sharp and sudden in the still house. Maggie turned her head, catching a quick glimpse of a tall shadow against the wall before the oak door opened inward.

Heavy footsteps sounded along the back porch planks, followed by the storm door’s metallic latch clicking open. A sudden gust of icy ocean air swept into the kitchen, carrying the sharp tang of salt spray and cut timber that rattled the paper teacups resting on the sideboard.

Arthur entered the doorway, his tall frame filling the opening. He wore a dark canvas work jacket, pine needles clinging to his sleeves, and a wool knit cap pulled low over his brow. Tucked beneath his left arm was a sack of split oak firewood, while his right arm cradled two large brown paper grocery bags against his chest.