Page 42

Ben sat at the head of the table, accepting the gravy boat from Maggie and passing it toward his daughter with a relaxed comfort that felt remarkably natural. It showed that a new rhythm had taken shape in their home. Beside him, Theo was enthusiastically spreading sweet butter onto his sourdough roll, his shirt sleeves pushed up to his elbows as he chattered happily about school friends, building snow forts with Eli almost daily, and his woodcarving progress at the shop.

Laura sat beside her son, listening with a bright, affectionate smile, occasionally glancing across the table at her father with quiet happiness. Maggie completed the circle near the sideboard, serving warm carrots onto Theo’s plate and pouring sweet apple cider into stoneware tumblers with easy grace, fitting into the family setting as if she had belonged there all along.

As they ate, the conversation turned smoothly into fond memories of past holiday seasons. Laura set her silver fork down on her plate, her eyes sparkling with humor as she looked over at her father. She brought up the famous Christmas all those years ago when Ruth had attempted a brand-new recipe for cranberry pie and accidentally omitted the sugar entirely, resulting in a dessert so intensely tart that everyone’s eyes watered on the first bite.

Laura recounted how her mother had proudly insisted that the pie was naturally tart and required everyone to take at least two polite bites, until Ben quietly hid his remaining slice beneath a paper napkin while her back was turned toward the sink.

Ben let out a loud, rumbly laugh, his broad chest shaking under his wool sweater as the vivid memory returned. He added the story of the holiday during the big blizzard when Ruth had accidentally substituted coarse salt for granulated sugar in her batch of sugar cookies, turning the festive treats into rock-hard salty biscuits that nobody could chew without grimacing. Laura wiped a tear of laughter from her cheek, her shoulders shaking as she recalled trying to dunk her salty cookie into hot tea.

Tonight, Ruth’s memory didn’t bring the deep sadness of her loss. It brought warm, cathartic laughter that echoed off the timber rafters and filled every corner of the saltbox kitchen with genuine joy.

Maggie listened with a radiant smile, contributing her own amusing story about a lopsided gingerbread house from her childhood that had collapsed into a sticky pile of frosting ten minutes before her grandparents arrived for tea.

The four of them shared the warm meal together, passing dishes, pouring cold milk, and enjoying the easy, comfortable rhythm of a true home. Laura looked across the table at Maggie with genuine affection, asking about the town’s upcoming Christmas Wish Supper at the community hall.

When the meal wrapped up, Laura and Theo offered to gather the empty stoneware dishes and clear the table. Theo picked up his napkin, eagerly telling his mother every detail about the last few months. Laura smiled, taking her son’s hand and leading him up the wooden staircase to inspect his bedroom decorations, leaving Ben and Maggie standing alone in the kitchen.

Ben turned off the faucet after rinsing the last of the dishes, wiping his calloused hands on a dry cotton towel. He hung the towel over the sink rail and moved across the floor to stand beside Maggie near the sideboard. He peered down at her, taking in her expressive blue eyes, her rosy cheeks, and the gentle, peaceful expression resting on her face.

Ben reached out, his large hand gently wrapping around hers. He looked straight into her eyes with unreserved conviction. “I think I’m starting to fall deeply in love with you,” Ben said, his voice full of honest emotion.

Maggie’s eyes widened slightly with a touch of sweet elation, her breathing picking up. She turned her hand over, clasping his fingers tightly with her own. “I have to admit I feel the same way, and also confess that it scares the life out of me,” Maggie replied with a huffed chuckle.

Ben grinned, tugging Maggie closer to him and sighing from how right it felt. “We can be scared together, then.”

MAGGIE

A week before Christmas, the afternoon sun shone with very little heat over Harbor Square, casting slender shadows across the brick plaza facing the docks. The icy breeze whistled through the rigging of the moored fishing schooners, carrying the scent of salt, dried kelp, and old evergreens.

In the center of the square stood the massive Wish Tree, its dark green branches heavy with pinecones, paper wish envelopes, hand-carved ornaments, and hundreds of tree lights.

Maggie held the wooden handle of a shallow cedar crate. Her fingers were warm within her leather gloves. Beside her, Ben carried a larger pine chest containing dozens of his hand-carved dory models and white pine star ornaments for the Mistletoe Market booth.

Theo bounded alongside his mother Laura, his red knitted beanie bright against his dark coat as he pointed toward the decorated wooden booths lining the perimeter.

Across the cleared plaza, near the green iron bench, sat Vivian, wrapped in a thick quilt with a brass thermos of hot tea resting on her knee. She was calling out gentle directions to a pair of volunteers hanging green garland along the wooden booth arbors. Higher up near the middle branches of the Wish Tree, Arthur stood on a tall wooden ladder, adjusting a long strand of lights around the thick evergreen trunk.

Maggie set her wooden crate down on the long display table near the Christmas Wish Society booth, smoothing the red linen tablecloth over the top. The atmosphere in the square was lively and filled with cheerful preparations, but not for the first time in the past week and a half, her own heart felt completely at peace. Standing beside Ben in the open afternoon light, holding his hand as they navigated the plaza, she no longer felt the nagging pull of past doubts. They had chosen a real future together, built on honesty, respect, and mutual trust.

Ben set his heavy chest onto the table beside her, resting his calloused hands against the pine trim as he looked up at the towering fir. “The committee has outdone itself this season,” Ben noted, his voice pleasant in the cool air. “The tree looks sturdier than it did last winter.”

“Two full days were spent securing the guy wires behind the trunk,” Maggie explained, her eyes following the line of lights stringing through the needle boughs. “The goal was to make sure the sea wind wouldn’t tilt the top before the festival night.”

Theo ran over to the base of the tree, looking up into the high green branches with wide, curious eyes. “Where is the special heart ornament? The old one that’s on it every year?”

Maggie pointed toward a bough about nine feet off the ground, near Arthur’s feet where he stood on the ladder. “It’s hanging right beside the silver bell.”

Ben leaned closer, his eyes narrowing slightly as he examined the dark piece of wood suspended from a faded green ribbon. The carved wooden heart was weathered to a deep, dark chestnut hue, its edges smoothed by nearly forty winters of ocean wind and salt spray. As the breeze swung the heart gently against the pine needles, the sunlight caught the bottom surface of the ornament.

Ben took two small steps closer to the lower boughs, his sharp eyes catching a subtle detail. “Look at the base of the grain,” Ben said, gesturing toward the bottom of the ornament.

Maggie leaned in beside him, peering up into the green branches. “What do you see?”

“There’s a tiny mark cut into the wood beneath the lighthouse image,” Ben explained with genuine interest. “It’s an old-fashioned shipwheel with a small, rounded chisel point. That isn’t a decorative accent.”

Maggie looked at the small carving, her interest instantly piqued. “What is it then?”

“It’s a boatbuilder’s mark,” Ben replied, resting a hand on his hip. “Forty years ago, every master shipwright and carver along the harbor used a personal symbol on their custom wood pieces. My grandfather used an anchor notch, and the Miller yard used a triple pine needle. That shipwheel belonged to the old Hale yard down near the south pier.”