Page 34

Cian didn’t tell me to calm down. He didn’t defend Mom, promise revenge, insist Henry would come back to me, or claim time would make Salvatore easier to lose. He stayed on the floor and held me while grief took the last of what I had been using to stand.

His heartbeat moved steadily beneath my cheek. It was not Salvatore’s, and his arms could never become the arms of my husband. I didn’t need them to. Love didn’t heal by replacing what had been taken. Sometimes it endured because someone was willing to sit inside the emptiness and ask for nothing in return.

Cian couldn’t give me back my husband or my son. He couldn’t return the years when I should have known I was his daughter. But there, on the living room floor, he held me through the ruin of all of it. And for the first time in my life, I understood what it meant to break in a father’s arms without fearing he would punish me for the wreckage.

CHAPTER NINE

Late Spring 2025, Boston

The first thing I noticed inside my father’s apartment was my mother’s coat hanging beside his. The sight stopped me just beyond the elevator, one hand still clenched around my purse strap while the doors slid shut behind me and carried away the easiest escape.

Cian had asked me to meet him for dinner. He hadn’t mentioned Mom would be there, but I didn’t believe he’d arranged an ambush. Since the night at Duncan’s house, he had loved us both without asking me to forgive her or pretending he could mend what she had broken.

“Maddie?” Mom’s voice came from his office, soft with surprise and immediate caution. “Is that you?”

I could have stepped back into the elevator and left before she appeared. Instead, I walked toward Cian’s office.

“Cian was called to Sal’s office,” she said. “He tried to reach you, but you must have already been in the elevator.” Her gaze moved over my face. “If you want to leave, I won’t stop you.”

The permission hurt more than pressure would have. Mom stepped aside and let me decide whether the distance between us would survive another day.

“Did you really not know?” I asked.

The question followed me through every room of Cian’s apartment. It waited while Mom sat behind his desk with Eamon’s files spread before her and Valentino Valentinetti’s name glowing on the computer screen. It waited while I studied the strain around her eyes and the careful way she kept her hands folded, as if reaching for me without permission might send me back through the elevator doors.

Weeks had passed since I learned Cian was my father. I had spoken to him almost every day and allowed him to build something new from a love that had always existed without its proper name. But I had avoided every conversation with Mom that might force me to decide whether understanding her fear was the same as forgiving what she had done.

She bit her lip instead of answering. Her eyes closed against tears that came too quickly to belong only to that afternoon, and I knew she was afraid of losing me again. The knowledge should have softened me. Instead, it hurt to realize she understood exactly how much truth could cost and had still denied it to me for twenty-nine years.

“You can tell me the truth, Mom. I know I hurt you, and I might get angry, but I won’t run away. Not again.”

The promise frightened me as soon as I made it. Running had saved Henry from Nolan. For the first six months of his life, Salvatore and I had given him nothing but unconditional love. But it had also become the answer I reached for whenever staying demanded more courage than leaving.

Mom opened her eyes as a tear slipped down her cheek. She shook her head and stood. “Let’s go back to the kitchen. This conversation needs something to drink.”

I followed her out of Cian’s office, past the photographs and small ordinary signs that her life had begun fitting itself around his. Her shoes rested beside his near the elevator. Her scarf hung from the back of a dining chair, and a book I recognized as hers lay face down beside his reading glasses. She had finally stepped into the life she might have shared with him decades ago, but neither of them looked restored by the delay.

Mom reached for the coffeepot, and I stopped her before habit could answer for both of us. “Neither of us wants coffee.”

Her laugh was fragile, but it was real. I filled the kettle and set it on the stove. Cian had bought it after one of the nights I came to him because Nolan’s house felt too dangerous for honesty. Back then, I had believed he kept tea for an indulged niece. Now every small kindness carried the history of a father loving his daughter without knowing why his heart had chosen her so completely.

I took down two cups and found the tea in the pantry. Mom watched me move through his kitchen, her expression unreadable until I placed everything on the counter and sadness tightened her mouth.

“I didn’t know he kept tea,” she said softly.

“He didn’t, not at first. I used to come here when I needed to talk, and one night I mentioned I liked tea better than coffee. The next time I visited, he had all of this.” I shrugged, but the gesture couldn’t make the memory smaller.

I had gone to Cian because his apartment existed beyond Nolan’s reach. There were no carefully placed ears behind the walls, no husband waiting to turn a daughter’s confidence into another reason to punish his wife. That didn’t mean Mom had failed to love me, but pain changed the shape of every explanation it touched, and I could see rejection forming in the silence between us.

“I’m sorry I wasn’t there when you needed me.” She wiped at a tear and turned away.

“Mom, no.” I caught her arm gently and drew her back. “That isn’t what I meant. You were there for me. There were just things I couldn’t risk Nolan hearing.” She nodded, but I could tell the answer had not reached the wound. “It wasn’t that I didn’t trust you. I never believed you would tell him anything I asked you to keep private. But ...”

The suspicion had lived in me for years without proof. Nolan knew when I lied about where I had gone, who had called, and why I returned home carrying a happiness he had not permitted. Loving Salvatore had made secrecy instinctive, yet even my careful lies seemed to reach Nolan before I did.

“But what?” Mom asked.

“Sometimes I wondered if the house was bugged.”