AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Magdalene Cruthers Is Going To Hell

Page 50

by Ali Lockhart

Lou made a guttural sound. “What an interesting choice.”

“I was the only child, so she doted on me.”

Maggie realized her error immediately. She jerked her head up to Lou, whose face was blank.

“I mean, of course I wasn’t an only child, I had the boys.” This was why she had the story lined up, to avoid these easy slips. This is why falling into comfortability was dangerous. This was why she didn’t have any friends.

“They’re quite a bit older than you,” Lou said quickly. “I imagine they were out of the house by then, so you may as well have been an only child.” She looked up at Maggie, unblinking.

A silent offer. Maggie stared at Lou, her relief fizzling in her brain, her heart thundering. “We have different fathers,” she said weakly.

“I know.”

“We really do,” Maggie repeated, and they did. This truth was unflinching, and Lou seemed to realize it. “But they’re my brothers.” She inhaled, shakily. “They are.”

“I know, Maggie. I know you love each other.” Lou’s tone was uncharacteristically gentle, and Maggie didn’t know what to do with it. “Can I ask you something else?”

Maggie felt a muscle in her neck tic. “Yes.”

“Can you bring a loaf of bread to dinner? We’re out and I didn’t have time to bake some.”

Maggie let out a breath. “Of course. I hope Stinson’s is all right.”

“Naturally.” Lou hesitated. “Also, and I’m sorry to ask this, but …”

Maggie tilted her head. “What?”

Lou pursed her lips. “Please be careful with Theo. He’s more fragile than he looks. He always has been. His pain was the hardest thing I’ve witnessed, and I can’t bear the idea of it happening again.”

Maggie had rarely felt so raw. She swallowed. “Theo is very precious to me.” It felt like a confession—it was a confession—and Lou visibly relaxed.

“I think you’re precious to him, too, Magdalene.”

Dinner was, indeed, a roast. The chicken was tender, and, as Theo proudly proclaimed, butchered and cleaned by David (sourced from Edgar Hawk, the primary poultry breeder in the tri-county area, relevant name purely coincidental), which added a personal flair that was both sweet and slightly morbid. The potatoes were, indeed, a bit more thin than one would normally anticipate mashed potatoes to be, but Theo’s beaming expression was too beautiful to break, so she smiled and swallowed them down without a word. The dripping gravy was rich and salty, and paired perfectly with the bread she had purchased from a cheerful Mr. Stinson. Maggie used a slice to sop up the leftover juices from amid the scattering of chicken bones peppering her plate. “Perfect,” she said, sipping the pale white wine he had poured. “Really, Theo, it was delicious.”

He smiled over his steepled fingers. “Was it better than your cooking?”

She scoffed. “An old shoe is better than my cooking, I’m sorry to say.” She pushed her empty plate away, placing a hand on her full stomach. Her corset dug into her ribs sharply, and she shifted in her seat.

“How is Lou doing at the shop?” Theo held his wine glass in front of him, swirling. She watched those nimble, clever hands turn the glass, rotating it as the wine climbed the sides, nearly spilling. It didn’t, of course; Theo didn’t let bad things happen if he could help it.

“Good. Excellent. She’s invaluable.” It was true. Nurtured talent aside, Lou’s dogged determination to succeed was its own force. “We’ve become friends, I think. As friendly as Lou can be, maybe."

“Have you gone to the book club yet?” His smile was wine-bright, his eyes—God, she hated to say it—twinkling.

“No. I think she intends to take me the next time they meet. I’m glad I can finally find something to fill all my empty hours.”

Theo laughed. It was some sort of witchcraft, that sound, and made the hairs all over her body stand at attention. “Laura has been part of it for a few years. She has always found it pleasant.”

“I doubt Laura has found much to be unpleasant, with the possible exception of your parents.”

“She told me once that Janey Thurson suggested they read The Life and Times of Frederick Douglass after he received his vote for president last year.”

“And did they?”

“Oh, yes. Why do you think we’re all so revolutionary?”

Maggie nodded around the kitchen. “You are, though. Who knew a man could make such a succulent roast?”