AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Thin Line Between Love and Hate

Page 72

by Gwyn McNamee

When I left Cape Blackwell and Father behind me, I buried the memories of that night so deep that I rarely thought of it. Until it had almost become nothing more than a vague nightmare from another lifetime. But now I am tearing open that old wound, exposing the viscera of what made me never want to return to the Manor again.

I take a few moments to gather my thoughts and my wits before I attempt to begin to answer him, and Ellis gives me that time, quietly watching while he sips at his drink beside the fire. Finally, I inhale a deep breath and launch into it.

“Natalie was my best friend of any of the girls. We were always together, spending the night at each other’s houses, sitting together in every class, slipping each other notes about the boys we liked and the girls we hated.” I give him a tight smile. “Until I realized what a snake she was…”

“What’d she do?”

There were so many things over the years. Things I ignored or pushed aside without question rather than risk losing the person I believed to be my one true friend. But some things can’t be so easily brushed away.

“One of those nights that she spent here, we had gone to bed in my room hours earlier, but when I woke in the middle of the night, she wasn’t there. Not in my bed. Not in my room.”

Even after all this time, the feeling of confusion when I woke alone that night still feels so real. So immediate.

I’ve never told anyone this story.

Not a single soul.

And finally revealing it simultaneously feels like a weight being lifted from my shoulders and a stake being driven through my chest.

“I came down and looked in here first, expecting to maybe find her sitting by the fire and reading a book or something if she couldn’t sleep since I did that so often.” I shrug and motion toward the huge shelves filled with books. Of course, not Father’s special collection, but all the ones in here were like another set of friends. “She wasn’t here. There was only a blanket she had been using on the couch. I thought she may have gone to the kitchen to get a snack, so I headed toward the rear of the house, and that’s when I heard Father’s voice.”

Ellis’ back stiffens, his hand tightening on the glass, almost as if he can anticipate what I’m about to reveal.

“I inched over to his study door that was cracked and peeked in and saw Natalie perched on the edge of the desk while my father sat in his chair, chatting like old friends. But the way she crossed her legs in the tiny sleep shorts, angling toward him…I almost threw up then and there in the hallway.” Bile threatens to come up now, mixed with the harsh scotch sloshing in my stomach, but I choke it down. “Because I knew that move. I had seen her use it on every boy she was interested in in the entire fucking school.” Tears burn in my eyes and finally begin to fall. “And this was my goddamn father.”

Ellis swallows thickly, and I finally make my way back over to him, needing the warmth of the fire to burn away the chill of the memory.

“I knew I had to do something. Had to intervene. So, I went back into the kitchen and intentionally dropped a glass jar of pickles from the fridge. Within seconds of the sound, heavy footsteps pounded down the hall, followed by a softer set, and Father flipped on the lights. He saw the mess and glared at me with that same reproach his eyes always seemed to hold. He demanded to know what the fuck I was doing. I told him I was hungry.” I snort and shake my head, imagining how ridiculous I must have looked in my pajamas standing in the kitchen with pickles around my feet. “He just looked at me and said, ‘For pickles? At two a.m.?’ I didn’t know what to say. I kept peering over his shoulder at where Natalie stood, her eyes wide and worried. Because she didn’t believe me for a second. And I don’t think Father did, either. In fact, I know he didn’t.”

“How?”

Besides the fact that I’ve always been a terrible liar, that man could always read me like a book. The way he looked at me that night, I know he saw it—the accusation, the reproach, the disgust at what I had witnessed.

But that ultimately wasn’t how I knew.

I received an unequivocal confirmation.

“Because the next day, he sent me away to boarding school.”

Ellis’ eyes widen. “What?”

I nod, and then down the rest of my drink with another hiss. “All of us girls, the entire crew, had been planning to attend the private high school here, which is one of the best in the country, but it would have meant me staying at the Manor and living with Father. Natalie came back to my room with me that night, but we didn’t say a single word to each other before she went home the next morning. Later that day, Father told me he was sending me to St. Mary’s in Connecticut. He said I had an hour to pack everything I wanted to take with me and that they would get me settled into the dorms before school started in three weeks. Then he shoved me into a limo and didn’t even say goodbye.”

That day changed everything.

That day changed me.

Ellis reaches out for me and tugs me up against him. Despite how agitated I am, I allow him to because I don’t trust myself not to collapse to the floor otherwise.

I bury my face to his chest, and he presses his lips to the top of my head, holding me steady when I can’t do it for myself, just as he has countless other times. His cool ocean scent fills my lungs, replacing that of the scotch and the strange phantom smell of pickles, and it instantly soothes away some of the agitation making me restless.

“My God, Lorelei, I’m so sorry. I had no idea.” He sighs into my hair, running his fingers through the strands softly. “It makes bringing Natalie here even worse than I thought for you.”

“You didn’t know.”

“You never spoke to her again after that?”

I shake my head and pull back, then swipe at my tears with my free hand, still clutching the empty glass in the other. “She tried to call me at my new school a few times, probably to come up with a stupid bullshit explanation, but I didn’t want to hear it. I knew it would be a lie, and I didn’t have the stomach for it.”