Page 147
The light left Nancy’s eyes, and her shoulders sagged into the floral chair. “Her father.” Her mouth twisted. “My rotten brother, Gordon.”
“They didn’t get on?”
“Gordon was a violent drunk and a useless father.” Nancy looked down at her hands.
“What about Katrina’s mother?”
She sighed. “Sally died in a car accident when Katrina was nine.”
“Oh, no. That’s terrible.”
“Yeah. Gordon went off the rails after that. I used to love him. I felt sorry for him, you know, because he was my brother. But when Sally died, something broke inside him, and Gordon never recovered. He lashed out at anyone who got close enough.”
She twisted her hands together, knuckles bulging.
“A few years after Katrina vanished, Gordon robbed a bank. Shot a teller during it. The poor man survived, thank God, but Gordon was sentenced to twenty years in jail.” She paused. “Then he murdered another inmate while he was inside. They added more time to his sentence. He never got out. Gordon died in prison after serving nearly thirty-four years.”
Jesus. I hadn’t expected that. “I’m sorry.”
“I’m not.” Her answer came sharp and immediate. Then her face crumpled. “God forgive me, but I’m not.”
I had nothing to say to that, so I didn’t try.
Nancy drew a shaky breath. “When Katrina disappeared, I thought Gordon had done something to her. We all knew she was frightened of him. We knew why she ran.” Tears gathered in her eyes. “And then he wouldn’t talk about her. Wouldn’t look for her. He carried on as though his own daughter had never existed.”
“You believed he’d killed her?”
“For fifty years.” Her chin trembled. “I believed my brother murdered his little girl and hid her somewhere we’d never find her.”
A tear tracked slowly down her cheek.
“I hated him for it. Then sometimes I’d wonder if I was wrong, and I’d hate myself instead. What kind of sister believes a thing like that about her own brother?”
“The kind who knew what he was capable of,” I said softly.
Her gaze lifted to mine through the screen.
“But he didn’t kill her,” she whispered.
“No.”
Whit had established that much. Gordon might have been violent. He might have been a terrible father and an even worse man. But he hadn’t murdered his daughter.
Katrina had escaped him. She’d run from that house and whatever had been happening inside it, only to cross paths with three teenage boys far worse than the man she’d fled.
“It’s a wicked thing to feel relieved about.” Nancy wiped her cheek with the heel of her hand. “My niece is still dead. My brother was still a monster.”
“You’re allowed to be relieved.”
“Doctor Callahan said something similar to me.” Her lips trembled into a faint smile.
After fifty years of suspicion, hatred, and guilt, Whit had given the answers that had finally lifted that burden from her.
A terrible mercy. But still some small mercy.
Nancy’s eyes suddenly brightened. “I have a photograph of Katrina. Would you like to see it?”
“Yes. Of course I would.”