Page 174
Was Hatter seriously suggesting a watering can was the answer to my baby daddy dilemma?
Every head in the room turned.
Hatter was examining his palm like he was checking for potting soil. He looked up at the silence and blinked at us with the innocent confidence of a man who had no idea he’d just detonated a conversational grenade.
“What?”
Chess’s grin was nowhere to be found.
“You want to get Alice pregnant with . . . gardening tools?”
“Think about it,” Hatter went on, completely oblivious to the expressions on all of our faces. “When I’m feeding my plants, I don’t add just one nutrient to the watering can. I mix everything together. The fertilizer, the trace minerals, the bone meal—”
“I’ll volunteer my bone meal,” Callister said with a deviant grin.
I made a noise that was somewhere between a groan and a scream.
Jack closed his eyes like he was asking a higher power for patience. Or death. Possibly both.
Hatter blinked at Callister, completely missing the bone meal innuendo, and continued like he hadn’t been interrupted.
“—pour it all in, give it a little stir, and let the soil decide what it needs.” He shrugged. “Same principle. All of us contribute to the watering can. Pour it in Alice. See which one of us takes root.”
Nobody spoke.
Nobody breathed.
“Alice’s brain doesn’t have to decide,” he added helpfully. “Her body can do it for her!”
I watched in real time, in high definition, with my full cognitive faculties engaged, as five supernatural men exchanged looks. Chess to Ransom. Ransom to Callister. Callister to Jack. Jack back to Ransom.
And I watched . . . with the slow, creeping horror of a woman watching a building collapse in slow motion . . . as every single one of them arrived at the same conclusion.
They were considering it.
They were actually considering the watering can plan.
My boyfriend had just compared my uterus to a flower bed, compared their cum to fertilizer, proposed that they all jerk off into what was essentially a communal jug, pour it inside me, and let nature take its course—
And these motherfuckers were NODDING.
“Oh, HELL no!” I screeched.
Meanwhile, more thoughtful nodding continued.
“Absolutely not!”
More nodding.
“Have you guys even seen Hatter’s watering can?” I threw my hands up in the air. “That thing is filthy! It’s got dirt and bugs in it! And all the other shit you’ve been mixing into your fertilizer! For all I know, there is actual shit in that thing! I’ve seen mushrooms growing inside it, you guys! Mushrooms!”
Chess gave me a sympathetic look.
“The watering can was a metaphor, Alice.”
“Was it, though? Because Hatter looks very literal right now.”
“We don’t need an actual watering can, bunny,” Ransom said, and the calm authority in his voice made me want to throw something at him. He was using his mafia demon daddy voice. His Dom with a second home in Hell voice. His I’ve-run-a-sex-club-for-centuries-and-nothing-shocks-me voice. “Keep it sanitary. Safe.” He paused for effect, like the smug bastard he was. “And sexy as fuck.”