Page 192
"Sometimes. When Father allowed it."
"Did they have toys?"
"A few."
My stomach turns. I've spent the last few weeks discovering how wonderful the world can be when someone lets you experience it. Those children were upstairs the entire time, and nobody even told me they existed. "Did Harlow know?"
Abigail nods.
"Was she helping them?"
“Ruth helped whoever she could."
I remember the night Father killed her. She argued with him about people who couldn't protect themselves. I thought she meant me. Now I wonder whether she was trying to protect seventeen other people as well. "Did he kill her because of them?"
Abigail's face closes. "I don't think we should talk about that today."
"But I want to know."
"They're safe now, Elizabeth. They have doctors, people looking after them, and somewhere they can play."
I look toward a little boy laughing beside the pond because a duck has splashed his shoes. I hope the children from Sanctum get to laugh like that. I hope nobody tells them they're wicked for making noise. Behind us, Felix's phone rings. He checks the screen and speaks briefly with the other agent before stepping toward a quieter stretch of path.
"It's my boss," he tells me. "Stay where I can see you, okay?"
"I will."
He gives me a small smile, then answers. I watch him for a moment, wanting to ask why he never told me about the children, although I know the investigation means there are things he isn't allowed to share. Abigail links her arm through mine. "Come along. We can keep walking."
"Felix said to stay where he can see me."
"And he can. We're only going around the flowerbeds."
She's right. I can still see him beside the pond, so I let her guide me along the path. "Did the children know about me?" I ask.
Abigail hesitates. "Some did."
"How?"
"They heard things."
I remember screaming in the basement. Sometimes I heard footsteps overhead afterward and wondered whether the wives were coming to help me. The thought that children might have heard me, frightened and helpless, makes my skin feel too tight. "They heard Father hurting me?"
"Sometimes."
I want to ask Felix about them. I want to know whether they have nightmares and whether someone holds their hands when they're frightened. But Abigail touches my shoulder before I can turn back. "There's something you should understand about Father," she says. "About why he treated you differently."
"I don't want to talk about him."
"Did you ever notice that he changed everyone's name except mine?"
I look at her. I hadn't noticed. I assumed Abigail was another name Father had chosen from the Bible. "He told me I was special," she continues. "That God had chosen me, and my name was already sacred."
I remember the white dress Father gave me when I was little, and how Abigail watched. She looked so angry that I thought I'd done something wrong. I never understood why she wanted Father's attention when I would have given anything to escape it. "You were jealous of me."
Abigail's smile trembles. "I thought I was the chosen one. Then he brought you home."
"I didn't want to be chosen."