AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Betting against the scoundrel

Page 27

by Mariah Stone

“I just…” She fingered with her gloved hands. “I hope you don’t find me too forward…” She’d climbed down a few steps and was now on the same level as he, looking up at him, so gentle and so tender and so much like the woman he’d loved…his first love. “I missed you. I miss you still. I just wondered if we can be friends again. Discuss art like we used to. And talk of anything…like before.”

Before everything. Before he had been press-ganged. Before Preston had married her. Before she had fallen in love with his brother.

Spencer’s throat clenched. His first love…only she wasn’t the woman he’d known, the woman he’d fallen for.

She’d changed. From the young lady he used to know who was shy and reserved, unsure of her own capabilities, she had grown into a woman who knew her own mind and her own worth. It was a transformation he was glad to see…one to which her love for his brother had, undoubtedly, contributed.

She used to be his friend. Someone with whom he had shared more of his thoughts than he had anyone else. Though nothing he had said was exceptionally personal nor plumbed the depths of his soul. He’d always preferred to keep things light and cheerful. Now he could barely remember that man.

“I don’t know,” he said, his voice hoarse. “I don’t know if I can.”

He didn’t know if he had anything to give to anyone anymore…as a friend or as anything else. The war and Ashton had robbed him of many physical things—had left him with a wounded leg, and other scars he couldn’t count.

But they had also robbed him of something else he couldn’t touch. Perhaps a piece of his soul.

He didn’t say this out loud, and she probably misunderstood his meaning. “I never meant to hurt you, Spencer. I am so sorry. For everything.”

His throat tightened, and he had to clear it to be able to force words out. He softened. He knew it wasn’t her fault. He was still angry, but it wasn’t with her, even though it was hard to talk to her.

“No, please, Penelope, you don’t have to explain yourself—”

“I need to say this, Spencer. You need to know my side of this. I never knew you had feelings for me. The whole time, I thought we were friends… That you were only interested in pursuing the skirts that fluttered so temptingly all around you, not serious about one person—and certainly not the shy girl who only cared about art. Had I known it was more for you than for me, I would have stopped our conversations.”

Rejection stung him. She would have stopped seeing him, being his friend had she known of his feelings… Had he proposed, she would have said no. This revelation was like a slap to his already bruised ego. It was always meant to be Preston for her. Not him. All his hopes had been futile. What did she see in his brother that she never saw in him?

The emotional slap cleared his mind, which immediately returned to Miss Digby, the thought of whom ignited a spark within him like nothing else did. Had Penelope ever had a similar pull for him? Was it possible that he’d not only deluded himself about her feelings but about his own? If so, why did it still hurt so much?

“I hope we can,” he said. “I mean it. One day, I hope we can be friends like before. But I have to be honest, I can’t see that day now.”

Penelope’s eyes moistened, and his chest tightened at seeing her sadness. He wished he had a better response, but this was all the hollow emptiness in the middle of his chest could offer.

With an arm that felt like it weighed two stone, he gestured towards his carriage, where Carl stood holding the open door.

They got into the carriage. When Carl began driving, Penelope tried to fill the way to the Ashtons’ with a polite, awkward conversation. This felt particularly strained, especially in contrast to the hours of easy back-and-forth they used to share…

But how could he tell her about the things that happened to him? About who he truly was now, the hunger and the strict discipline on the ship, the fear that had lived in the pit of his stomach like a fifth limb. Part of that fear came from being trapped on the seemingly fragile wooden vessel in the vastness of the ocean, part of it came from knowing enemy cannonballs would soon be flying through the air at them at an unimaginable speed. Once again, he felt the shower of splinters pierce his flesh, inhaled acrid smell of gunpowder that could mean death for him or his friends.

While he had been held prisoner in the first few days, he had met a young man, Sam Holter, from Whitechapel—the only man who had believed he was a duke. They had sat in the bowels of the ship together and talked. Spencer had developed great respect for the young man who had learned healing from his grandmother. Once they were released to do work around the ship and learn to sail and fight, aim and fire cannons, they became true friends, always there to help each other and provide moral support.

When Spencer’s thigh was injured, Sam was there for him through the darkest times. If Spencer had succumbed to infection, he wouldn’t have faced death in solitude. Sam had been next to him, holding his hand and offering comfort with calming words and a steady gaze.

How could a gentlewoman like Penelope ever understand that experience?

Like a proper duchess, she guided the conversation. She asked him questions, and he gave polite, meaningless replies when what he really wanted was to run away from all this unpleasantness. To distract himself, he thought about all the ways he’d outsmart Miss Joanna in their wager…and once he won their bet, how he’d stretch out the pleasure and savor the night when he’d make her his.

He needed only to get through this introduction, and he’d be much closer to his goal. Once he had the evidence and more information about Ashton’s activities, he would finally destroy the duke as he deserved.

Half an hour later, they stopped before Neverton Place, and his gut clenched at the memory of chasing his Persephone within these walls… The first time he’d seen her, he couldn’t look at anyone else.

She was the Persephone to his Hades.

Just when he needed her.

And now that he knew who she really was—delicious little Miss Joanna Digby—he wanted her even more.

The hunger to see her was an unsettling need in the middle of his body. He wanted to win their bet. To keep her out of danger and get his revenge against Ashton. Being her first would be the ultimate prize. Perhaps he should feel guilty about his plan. It could put her future in jeopardy. But he would take special care that she wasn’t found out…and there were ways for a lady to make a husband believe he was her first. And he needed her in a way that would not be denied…

In speaking with Ashton’s wife, he hoped to learn something that would get him ahead of the game, give him some clue about Ashton’s connection to Whitechapel. Perhaps he could discover more about the man who went to Petticoat Street on Sundays.