Page 49
He swallowed his food and studied her. “You won’t be. As I said, I will protect your reputation fiercely. And your virginity…women know many ways to fool a husband into thinking he married a virgin. So… Why did you assume you never would marry?”
She shrugged. “I’m not certain what it was exactly that made me think that. I suppose I always knew my place was in the background. Helping my sister and my brother.”
He narrowed his eyes. “That doesn’t sound like something you’d come up with by yourself… You’re too much of an independent thinker for that. You’re fearless and highly intelligent. You know what you want, and when it comes to protecting those you love, you do not hesitate. So being in the background is not your natural instinct. That must be something you learned. Like someone said that to you…”
Realization struck her at his words. She stopped tasting the food, her jaw stilled, her fork and knife forgotten in her hands. As the world around her came to a standstill, her mind drifted.
From her first memories, Joanna had always been happy making others happy. Where her brother and sister had cried and complained if someone took their toys, Joanna had cheerfully given them the toy she played with because seeing Charlotte’s and Gideon’s pleased faces made her feel so much better than upsetting them by keeping something. Being the youngest, she never had her own things and got only hand-me-downs from her sister. Often, the first ruddy apple of a new harvest, or the first strawberry of the year went to Charlotte. She also simply observed that people were naturally more drawn to her sister: the governess, the servants, her parents, other children, and visitors.
It was, however, the night she overheard her mama and papa talking that made her realize her true place…
“I think you’re right,” Joanna said, as her mind filled with the memory of an evening as she walked through the hallway in the darkness. “One night, I overheard Mama and Papa discussing our futures. Mama said, ‘I wonder why God sent us Joanna… We were so content with a boy and a beautiful girl. I never wanted another child.’ And Papa said, ‘You made it very clear to me, indeed.’ Mama rolled her eyes and said, ‘But you were drunk, and so Joanna happened.’ Mama sighed. ‘She’s so different from the others. She’s not as sociable as Charlotte nor as ambitious as Gideon. She’s always been content with her books and her little world.’
“Papa said, ‘She has a heart of gold, always putting others before herself. Remember when she gave up her new dress so Charlotte could wear it to the ball? Or when she stayed up all night to help Gideon to write that essay Monsieur Philippe had been so furious about?’
“‘Yes,’ Mama said, a hint of sadness in her voice. ‘She’s our rock. Always there to support, to comfort. But I fear she’ll never seek public notice for herself. She’s content to let others shine while she remains in the shadows.’
“Father murmured in agreement, ‘Perhaps it’s just her nature. Some are meant to be stars, while others…others are the quiet strength behind them.’
“‘And I can’t imagine anyone wanting to marry her,’ Mama said.”
She finished talking, a little dumbstruck at what had just come out of her mouth.
“I didn’t think about this memory at all…for years…” she said and met Spencer’s dark eyes, which were glistening with empathy and fury at the same time. “I think that was when I realized my place was in the background. That because my parents thought so, I deserved average things…average clothes…an average life. The best things were for Charlotte and for Gideon. And I made peace with that then. So much later, when we were adolescents, there was a boy I liked…you know, the first sort of feelings towards the opposite sex. His family visited us for the summer while Charlotte was away for a while visiting the Hodgeses. His name was Benjamin. With Charlotte gone, I felt his full attention… We read together, rode, played games…we grew to be exceedingly close friends. And for the first time in my life, I believed myself to be the foremost object of someone’s affection. But when Charlotte came back home, his attention completely switched as though I had never existed. Angry and feeling let down, I confronted Charlotte, but Mama said I was being selfish and that the boy wouldn’t have liked me anyway. That it’s not like I had a chance with him. And I knew then I was just too unexceptional to be anyone’s choice.”
Spencer carefully took the fork and knife, which she miraculously still clutched, from her hands. She felt tears prickling her eyes, the memories, the realizations like iron claws holding her in their prison. That’s why Spencer would never choose her, she realized now, because he had his own Charlotte—his sister-in-law Penelope. He’d realize now, just like Benjamin, that Joanna really wasn’t worth his time.
His warm hand was so lovely and comforting on hers. “Your mama and papa loved you, no doubt. But they boxed you and your siblings into roles based on their observations. Mine did the same. I was always the strong one. Preston was the ‘spare,’ so he wasn’t treated with as much attention. Richard even less so. But my sister, Calliope, was the princess—both for my parents and all of us boys, too. She was raised knowing she was loved and strong and free to do what she wanted. Your mama and papa mistakenly saw your incredible selflessness and kindness not for the strength that it really is, but as a weakness. They didn’t know that success and happiness can look differently. They failed to see that your nature can and should lead you to shine in your own right.”
Joanna felt like her lungs were full of air and tight, about to burst through her chest.
“Your sister and brother don’t know how lucky they are to have you,” he said. “Your parents didn’t know their biggest treasure was born as their third child. I can only feel sorry for them for not noticing that. You, my dear, are certainly not in the background to me. You stand so far in the foreground, I fail to see anyone else but you.”
His acceptance, his understanding were almost as heartbreaking as his words of praise. Joanna felt a warmth spread through her, a feeling she hadn’t known she craved until this very moment. His gaze held hers, unwavering and sincere, and she felt seen, truly seen.
“Let us work together, Joanna,” he said, throwing another shock at her.
She blinked. “Pardon?”
“We have the same goal but for different reasons and with different consequences. But clearly when we work together, we’re stronger. What if we can get what we both need? We get the evidence. You take it to Ashton and first get him to give you back the deed and ensure your sister is safe from the prince. Afterward, I punish him by starting a criminal case against him. I want him punished, Joanna. He deserves it.”
Joy flowed through her. She was not sure how or why, but she liked his plan. “What made you change your mind?” she asked.
“My family.” He smiled. “If anyone made a similar proposition to my sister as the prince regent did to yours, I’d break their neck. I can’t break the prince regent’s neck—that would be treason. But I know what it’s like to try and protect your family with all your heart. That is what I’d do, too. And I don’t want to make it more difficult for you than it already is. I think we can do both. Achieve your goal and mine. Do you have an objection?”
“If Ashton is convicted, Gideon will never be duke like he’s supposed to.”
“Perhaps not. Or perhaps we can get the Crown to allow him to keep the duchy, given your help in finding evidence of his crimes. And even if he will never be duke, he’ll have his deed and his fortune from his papa. That’s not a small feat, is it? That would allow you to stop writing for money and for him to stop working as a solicitor. It would allow you all to improve your lives and not struggle anymore.”
“That is true. Though I don’t want to stop writing for money. I’d always like to—actually, I’d like to start a newspaper where women could be published under their own names. And publish women exclusively.” She had been thinking about this a great deal, and it was the best way she could devise to help women claim some power in their world, to gain a voice no one could silence.
He was a little speechless at that, watching her with wonder in his eyes. “You’re quite extraordinary. I’ve never met a woman like you, Joanna.”
She beamed, his compliment like sun on her skin.
“Come on, Joanna,” he said. “Let’s become allies.”
Allies…with this beautiful man. She wanted to be on the same side as him, working together. She could tell him about the note, about the date, the word “Valiant” and the mysterious numbers, geographical names of Portsmouth and Chesapeake Bay. She wanted to trust him.