Page 34
That makes her laugh, but I catch the pink that tinges her cheeks as she shakes her head. “No, he’s not my type.”
“Ah, so it’s Sawyer who’s caught your eye then?” I ask in understanding. He was everyone’s type… unfortunately.
“Ah, no, sorry. Your brothers are attractive and all, but neither of them is my type.”
Does that mean she’s attracted to me? I tilt my head as I study her. What kind of girl isn’t attracted to a firefighter or sheriff? “What’s your type then?” I ask curiously.
Her lips twitch as she replies, “Skinny and dumb.”
That makes me laugh, and I can see the little liar’s cheeks turn pink. “I think you need to take a shot,” I say with a grin.
“I answered!” she replies curtly.
“Not honestly.” I raise an eyebrow at her as if daring her to lie again. She just narrows her eyes at me and grabs her glass, opting to take the shot instead of answering honestly. Interesting, I wonder what her type actually is. It’s possible she doesn’t know; not everyone does.
She twists her lips as she glances at me, then she must get a burst of courage from the drinking because she blurts out, “Look, you and your brothers seem really nice, but I’m not here to get my heart broken.”
“Damn, someone really did a number on you, huh?” I ask, unable to hold my tongue.
She narrows her eyes but nods, surprising me. “Not someone, someones. Everyone I’ve met in Chicago is just trying to get ahead, always looking for the next best thing, whether that’s their job, their home, or their partner.”
“That sounds exhausting,” I say with a frown.
“Exactly!” she says, throwing her arms up in exasperation. “That’s why I left.”
“Don’t give up,” I tell her softly. “Sounds to me like you just haven’t met the right guy yet.”
“Duh,” she says with a grin as she rolls her eyes. “What about you? Your brothers already told me you were all single, but is there someone you’re interested in?”
I let out a sigh as I let my head rest back and stare up at the ceiling, the alcohol loosening my tongue. “There was. A few years ago.”
“What happened to her?”
“She chose my brother over me. And the worst part? He didn’t even want her.”
“You still want her,” she guesses incorrectly, and I shake my head.
“No, I actually forgot about her until you just asked that question.”
She’s silent for a minute before she speaks, filling the growing silence between us. “It must be difficult, being an identical triplet.” I nod, and she continues. “I bet people compare you all the time.”
“You have no idea,” I huff out.
“If I were you, I’d remind myself that your brothers are both single, too.” I lift my head to look at her, and she shrugs. “I don’t pretend to know what you’re thinking or feeling, but I do have two siblings myself. And my mom is always comparing me to them. I hate it. No matter what I do, I can never be as good as them in her eyes.”
“That sucks,” I tell her.
“Yeah, well, the way I see it, their lives aren’t any better than mine. My sister’s been divorced three times, and my brother lost his license and has a gambling problem. So, as much as my mom likes to compare us, I know that I don’t want their lives.”
For someone I’d only known for an hour, Holly was already becoming one of the most insightful people I’d ever met. I don’t even think my own siblings knew why I went out drinking all the time, or why I stopped hanging out with them. I was jealous.
My old girlfriend, Margie, had told me she was into Sawyer as well and wanted a relationship with us both. We’d shared a couple of girls in the past, and we were so close I could see it working. But as soon as we had a threesome, she told me she didn’t feel that way about me anymore and that she just wanted Sawyer. So I backed off.
I didn’t see her around, so I’m not sure if they tried to date. I never asked because it didn’t matter; she made her choice. And my jealousy and anger started to grow. I started noticing how women looked at Sawyer or Wyatt before they’d even notice my presence. Having your identical brothers as the town Sheriff and a firefighter was impossible to compete against. So I stopped. I stopped dating, I stopped hanging out with them, I just… stopped.
I half expected them to say something, to tell me I was being stupid, but they barely noticed. Sure, they’d invite me to hang out with them, but even those invites stopped. Now we just live like roommates. I’m so estranged from them that none of my siblings thought to even tell me that my sister and nephew had been part of an armed robbery, almost getting killed.
Had I really sunk so low that they thought I wouldn’t care about them anymore? I glance over at Holly, who’s just silently sitting there, lost in her own thoughts, unaware of the turmoil going through my head. How was she able to cut through years of my bullshit with just a few simple questions?