Page 51
“I can see spending the rest of my life with her,” he admits.
“Fuck,” I curse, rubbing my hand down my face. “What do we do now? I don’t want her to come between us, but I also don’t want to back off.”
We’re all silent, lost in thought until Sawyer looks up at me, a grin pulling at his lips. “You know, the three of us,” he says, glancing at Griffin then back to me. “We used to be really good at sharing.”
My brows pinch in confusion as I try to understand what he means.
“Are you saying you want to share a girlfriend?” Griffin asks, not sounding completely put off by the idea.
Sawyer shrugs. “Why not? I’ve shared girls in bed with you both before, although never all three of us. And we like living together, so much so that it's caused rifts in our relationships before, right?” He looks at us both in question, and we slowly nod as the idea starts to take hold.
“Imagine not having to worry if your girlfriend’s going to like one of your brothers more, or if she’s going to get along with their girlfriend, or force us to move away. I don’t want to lose you guys, and maybe Holly is the key to that.”
Everything he’s saying has happened to us before, girls trying to get between us or they start dating one, only to realize they like another better. “How do we know she won’t choose one of us over the others?” I ask, eyeing Griffin, who she seems to be the closest with.
“Have you seen the way she looks at us?” Sawyer asks. “She’s definitely attracted to all of us. We just need to push her a little to see how she really feels.”
“How do we do that?” Griffin asks. “I don’t want to hurt her.”
“We won’t. I’m just saying that so far, we've been holding ourselves back, right?” I nod, and he continues. “Well, we stop doing that. We show her that we’re all interested and see what happens. If she pulls back from two of us, then we’ll know how she feels.”
“And if she doesn’t pull back, if she accepts all three of our advances…” Griffin starts.
“Then we’ll ask her to be our girlfriend,” Sawyer says with a smile. “So, what do you think?” he asks, looking eagerly between us.
“Okay,” Griffin says with a nod. “Let’s do it.”
They both look at me as Sawyer asks, “Wyatt?”
My eyes bounce between them until a grin spreads on my face. “I’m in.”
CHAPTER FOURTEEN
HOLLY
Imoan as Wyatt kisses down my neck, his hands roaming my body. Someone presses up behind me and kisses my shoulder. “Sawyer,” I whisper as he reaches around to squeeze one of my breasts.
“Kiss me,” Griffin whispers from my side, cupping my face and turning me to face him. He presses his lips to mine, and I get lost in their touch. My clothes seem to magically disappear, as do theirs, leaving nothing between us.
“Tell us you’ll stay,” Sawyer whispers in my ear before sucking on my earlobe.
“But you have to choose,” Wyatt says, breaking our kiss as he forcefully turns my face back to him. “Choose me,” he demands.
“No,” Griffin says, shoving Wyatt away. “Choose me.”
Sawyer turns me around to face him, cupping my face as his eyes narrow and he demands, “Choose me, Holly. I’ll give you the world.”
“I—” I cut myself off, unsure how to answer. “I want all of you,” I admit.
Sawyer looks at me in disgust, shoving me back hard as he seethes. “Slut.”
I gasp, my heart breaking as he turns his back and walks away. I turn around to find Wyatt and Griffin scowling at me, now fully dressed with their arms crossed over their chests. “I knew I couldn’t trust you,” Griffin says with a sneer before he turns and stalks away, disappearing into the darkness that surrounds me.
I look back at Wyatt and ask, “Do you hate me now, too?”
“Oh, Holly,” he tisks, stepping closer and lightly wrapping his hand around my throat. “I always hated you. That’s why I’m going to kill you.”
I gasp, and his hand tightens on my throat. I try to pry his hand off me, but it only makes him squeeze harder. He grins, and I watch as his blue eyes turn brown. The rest of his face starts to blur until it’s no longer Wyatt I’m looking at.