AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

A Favor for the Jock

Page 14

by Jenny Pineapple

“Did Zach ever say anything about that?” Sam asks, turning to me. “Weren’t they roommates for, like, two years?”

“No,” I say. “He never mentioned it. They’re still friends, I think, but it’s not like he debriefs me.”

“Huh.” Sam takes that in.

“Good for them,” Elliot says.

We both look at him.

“What?” He shrugs. “Three people who make each other happy and don’t care who knows about it. That’s hard to pull off. Good for them.”

He says it and goes back to his muffin, and I study my friend for a second. Because here’s the other thing: Elliot Walker keeps his private life to himself. All these years of friendship, and I couldn’t tell you a single person he’s ever been into. Not one. He shows up, he plays his games, he’s funny in a dry way, and his personal life stays behind a door he never opens.

The conversation moves on, but a question sits on the tip of my tongue for the next ten minutes. Before I can stop myself, I ask as casually as I can manage:

“How does a guy even know, though? If he’s into other guys.”

Sam’s head turns, and Elliot looks up from his muffin.

“I’m just curious,” I add, which is what people say when they’re not just curious.

“Hm.” Elliot considers it. “I think if you’re gay, you just know. Growing up, you figure it out the same way you figure everything else out. It’s just there.”

“Right, yeah.” I nod. “But what if it’s not like that? What if you’re into girls, like, definitely into girls, that’s established. And then somewhere along the way you find out you might be into guys, too? How do you know then?”

Sam studies me. “Why are you asking?”

“No reason. It’s just, the Sawyer thing got me thinking. Three guys, you know, how does that even…” I lift my coffee and drink, hiding the bottom half of my face behind the cup. “It’s a hypothetical.”

“A hypothetical?”

Elliot, mercifully, chimes in again. “I guess it’s the same as anything you want. You notice somebody. You keep noticing. Your body figures it out before your head does.” He glances at me. “At least that’s what I’ve heard.”

Interesting phrasing.

“Honestly,” Sam says, leaning back in her chair, “if you’re not sure whether you’re into your own gender, there’s really only one way to find out.”

“Which is?”

“Try.” She shrugs. “You can sit around theorizing forever, but at some point you just have to try it and see. That’s how you know.”

“That’s your advice?”

“It works for classes, it works for food, it works for people.” She grins. “How do you know you don’t like something until it’s in your mouth?”

“Sam.”

“What? I stand by it.”

Elliot huffs a laugh into his coffee, and we move on to whether the Wolves are going to choke against their rivals next week. I take part in the conversation, but Sam’s words stay with me.

You just have to try it and see.

I think about Zach’s voice describing slow builds and coming in waves, and how my whole body went still in the dark at his words, not with horror but with curiosity.

Two nights ago I called it pent-up energy, and maybe that’s still true. Or maybe I’ve been carrying a question my whole life without ever reading it, and all it took was watching my roommate pleasure himself.

I know I like girls. That part is real. But I also know that two nights ago I came with Zach’s name in my mouth, and that my stomach somersaults every time somebody says his name.