AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

A Favor for the Jock

Page 22

by Jenny Pineapple

“You live here. You don’t have to knock.” He’s still holding the blanket like a shield. “I just… I figured you were at the party.”

“I went, but I left early.”

“Yeah, I can see that,” he huffs.

I take off my jacket and drape it over the back of my chair, keeping my eyes on the desk so I don’t look at him directly. Out of the corner of my eye, I see Jamie shift on his bed and sit up, but he makes no move to get up and get dressed.

“I mean, obviously I didn’t expect you back, or I wouldn’t have—” He gestures with one hand. The blanket slips, and he grabs it again. “I was just, you know.” He clears his throat. “Handling something.”

“Yeah, I noticed.” Then it hits me. “Wait, why aren’t you on your date with Kenzie?”

I look at him directly and catch the flush on his face deepening. Jamie looks down at the blanket bunched in his fists, and his jaw clenches.

“It didn’t go very well.”

I straighten up. “What happened?”

“Nothing happened. That’s kind of the whole—” He drags a hand through his hair. “We had dinner, watched a movie. It was all going fine. And then it… wasn’t.”

“Wasn’t how?”

He gives me a pleading look, but I don’t let him off the hook. I wait.

“I wasn’t feeling it,” he says.

I frown. “What do you mean?”

He exhales through his nose, turns to the wall, and says it quickly. “I couldn’t get it up, okay?”

Silence.

“Okay,” I say finally.

“Okay?” His head whips around. “That’s all you’ve got? Okay?”

“I don’t know what you want from me, Jamie. I’ve never had that problem.” I let one eyebrow rise. “And for what it’s worth, that’s not what I just saw.”

He groans and covers his face with both hands, slumping back against his pillow. “I know. I know. Trust me, I’m aware it makes zero sense. At Kenzie’s, nothing. Then I get back here and—” He breaks off, pressing his palms harder into his eyes. “I don’t know what’s going on with me. I’ve never… that’s never happened. And it wasn’t her. She’s gorgeous. You’ve seen her, right? The whole thing was teed up, and I just… wasn’t there.”

My stomach does a slow roll. I know what he means by “wasn’t there.” For the past few days, I’ve been at the studio, in classes, at parties, thinking about this room the whole time. Thinking about what Jamie and I did that night. But I can’t let myself believe he means the same thing. If I’m wrong, I’ll have to move to a different state. I need to know, though. I’ve been desperate to find out what that night meant to him.

I sit down on my own bed across from him, elbows on my knees. The room smells of lube and his clean sweat. My cock twitches, and I ignore it.

“So what changed?”

Jamie lowers his hands from his face. “What?”

“Between Kenzie’s place and here.” I keep my voice level. “Something changed.”

He looks at me for a long moment, and his throat moves.

“I couldn’t stop thinking about it,” he says.

“About what?” I need him to say it.

He stares at me like I should already know, and the color in his face deepens as he says, “The thing you told me about. The—” He gestures toward his own lower half. “The prostate thing. How it felt. I couldn’t get it out of my head, and Kenzie was right there and it didn’t matter, because my brain was—” He swallows. “It was here. Thinking about that.”

The prickle under my skin, the one that’s been buzzing all evening, pitches higher.