AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

A Favor for the Jock

Page 24

by Jenny Pineapple

Holy fuck, he’s letting me do it.

I kneel between his legs, trying to keep my breathing steady, and pick up the lube from where it fell. I flip the cap and pour a generous amount over my fingers. Jamie’s cock twitches against his stomach as he watches me, and we haven’t even started.

I remind myself that, technically, this is a favor. I’m just here to teach him, nothing else.

I shift closer, one knee braced on the mattress, and reach down between his legs. At the first touch of my slick fingertips, circling the tight ring of muscle without pressure, Jamie’s whole body jerks.

“Cold?” I ask.

“No. No, it’s—just—” He blows out a breath. “Keep going.”

So I do. Slow circles, spreading the lube, feeling the muscle flutter under my fingertips. I’ve done this exact thing to myself, but doing it to Jamie is different. His thighs are tense under my forearm, and his chest keeps rising and falling, quick and shallow. Every time my finger passes over the center, his hips give a tiny, involuntary flinch.

“Try to relax. I know it’s hard. Just breathe out.”

He exhales, and his thighs loosen, though some tension remains.

“Good,” I tell him. “Just like that.”

I press the tip of my finger against him, wait until the muscle relaxes under the pressure, and then I push.

The first knuckle slides in, and I stop. He’s tight, hot, and clenched around me. I hold still and let him get used to it, watching his face. His eyes are shut and his jaw is tense, but when I look down, I notice that his cock hasn’t softened at all.

“Talk to me,” I say.

“It’s… weird.” His voice is already wrecked. “Not bad. Just… full.”

“It’ll fade. Give it a minute.”

I ease deeper, a fraction at a time, past the second knuckle, and the ring of muscle loosens around me by degrees. I let my finger rest inside him and wait. His breathing evens out, and his heels shift against the mattress.

Then his hips move. It’s small at first, a slow roll, him testing the sensation, pushing back against my finger. Then it happens again, firmer, and the sound he makes this time is lower, with something in it I recognize from that night earlier this week. His body opens around me, taking me to the last knuckle.

“Oh,” Jamie breathes. “Oh, that’s—”

“Yeah?”

His eyes are still shut, head tipped back, throat working. “Keep going.”

I start to move. Slow pulls and pushes, letting him feel every inch of it, and his hips pick up the rhythm. The golden retriever learns fast. His hands grip the sheets, and his cock leaks a fresh bead onto his stomach every time I push in. I watch and do my best to memorize it. I’ll think about this for the rest of my life. Whatever he decides he is tomorrow, I get to keep this. Jamie Foster open under my hand, fucking himself back on my finger.

I pull out slowly, and he whimpers at the loss.

“Shh,” I say before I can stop myself. “I’m right here.”

More lube, worked over two fingers. I press them together at his entrance and push. The stretch is greater this time, and his body resists for a breath before it gives.

“Fuck—” Jamie’s eyes fly open. “Jesus, your fingers are thicker than mine.” He laughs nervously, and the laugh breaks apart into a groan as I sink deeper. “Oh, wow.”

“Still good?”

“Yeah. Don’t stop.”

I don’t, but I go slow and deep, twisting a little on the way in. His hips meet every stroke, no hesitation left in him. I love hearing his low moans four inches from my face, knowing he’s making them because of me. His cock is leaking steadily onto his abs, twitching every time I bottom out.

I don’t touch it, though. We only agreed that I’d show him how to do prostate massage, and I don’t want to assume anything else. So I focus on my fingers inside him and remind myself: This is a favor. You don’t have him. You’re teaching him. Take what he gives you and don’t reach for more.

I curl my fingers slightly, searching, and on the third stroke I find the small, firm swell inside him. I crook my fingers and rub.