Page 34
“Fine.” Sam sits back and folds her arms. “I’ll start, since you’re being weird about it. Based on available evidence,” she says, gesturing at me, “your date with Kenzie was amazing.”
I cough into my coffee.
“I mean, look at you. You’re exhausted. Like you didn’t sleep at all. And you didn’t answer a single one of my texts. Plus, there’s a hickey the size of Lake Silver on your neck.”
I pull up the collar of my quarter-zip.
“So the math is mathing,” Sam continues. “Kenzie Lane rocked your world, and you just don’t want to brag about it. Which, honestly? Classy. I respect it. But I want confirmation.”
My stomach tightens. I can’t tell her the truth, but a lie would mean inventing a night with a girl who deserves better than to be my cover story.
“Actually,” I say, setting the coffee down, “it wasn’t that great.”
Sam blinks. “What?”
“The date wasn’t amazing.” I pick at the croissant, shredding the edge into flakes. “We had dinner, watched a movie, and then I went home early.”
Sam’s mouth opens, closes, opens again.
“What do you mean?” she asks finally. “Did you guys have a fight or something?”
“No, nothing like that.”
“Then what happened?” She frowns. “You’ve been talking about this date all week.”
That’s a stretch, but I don’t correct her.
“We watched a movie, then kissed for a while, and then…” I spread my hands. “I wasn’t feeling it, so we called it a night. She was actually really cool about it. Cooler than I deserved.”
“Oh no.” Sam covers her mouth. “Oh, babe. I’m so sorry.” She reaches across the table and pats my hand. “Are you really upset?”
“No,” I say, meaning it. “I’m fine. Really.”
“You don’t have to be fine.”
“I know. But I am.” I smile at her. “The vibe just wasn’t there. It happens.”
Sam studies me, her head tilted, her red hair sliding over her shoulder. “That’s so strange,” she says. “Because you came into brunch yesterday looking giddy, and I assumed it was about the date, but now you’re saying the date was a dud, and yet…” She waves a hand at my face. “You don’t look like a guy whose date flopped. You look wrecked, but in a good way. And by the way, who gave you—”
“Sam,” Elliot says. “Let the man eat his croissant.”
Sam nods and subsides, although I know she won’t let it go that easily.
I throw Elliot a grateful glance, and we eat in silence for a few minutes while I try not to think about Zach and his magical cock. It’s difficult, because the ache shifts every time I move in the chair, bringing back pieces of the night before. I drink my coffee, look out at the palm shadows on the walkway, and try to act like I’m fine.
“Can I ask something?” Elliot’s voice cuts into my thoughts.
He’s turned in his chair to face me, and I tense up. Elliot doesn’t do small talk.
“Sure,” I say, bracing myself.
“Do you and Zach always sleep naked around each other?”
Shit. So much for being grateful.
My ears burn. “Why—” I laugh, too high. “Why are you asking me that?”
“Just curious,” he says. “This morning, you answered the door in a sheet, and he was in his underwear. Neither of you seemed weird about it.” He tilts his head a fraction. “You two looked really comfortable around each other.”