Page 95
“We didn’t mean to be dating the same man,” May said, hurrying her words as if saying them fast made it better.
“We were all working part-time jobs so we could be available for casting calls, or the rare callback. What I mean is we were so busy we barely had time to talk,” Pat said.
“So when one of us started dating this great guy who worked part-time at the restaurant where we were working…” Susannah waggled her thumb between herself and May.
“Or the fabulous guy that I met at my receptionist job,” Nina said.
“Or the one I met at the gym where I was working reception and training clients part-time,” Pat said.
“Or the one I met while I was working at Saks Fifth Avenue,” Helena said.
“Are you saying it was all the same guy?” Galen asked.
They nodded and then laughed together. There was no bitterness, or envy, just shared memories. “It took us three weeks to figure it out,” Pat said.
“The fact that he dated all six of us in three weeks was sort of impressive,” Susannah said.
“It’s not as bad as it sounds, he didn’t know we were friends,” Helena said.
“Don’t try to be nice about him, Helena,” Pat said. “When he found out we were friends he wanted to keep dating us.”
“When he found out that Susannah and I were roommates, he wanted a three-way,” Nina said. All six women made eeww sounds and faces to match. I fought to keep my face neutral and not to look at Rhys or Galen, or Aisling.
“But there are no shared exes that would hold a grudge against all of you?” Jeremy asked.
They all said no. That there were exes who might hold a grudge individually but no one that would hate them all.
“My ex-husband hates me enough to do anything he could to hurt me, but he had no magical talent,” Susannah said, then seemed to think of something. “How much would it cost to hire someone to do a spell like this?”
“A lot,” Jeremy said.
“Define a lot?” she asked.
“Ten to twenty thousand to start, but for someone who you could trust to do the spell and not get caught by the police, a hundred thousand, or more.”
“Wow, my ex doesn’t have the money for even the lower end of that,” Susannah said.
“Did he ever meet all of you?” I asked.
“Once,” she said.
“No, not all of us,” Pat said. “I was working on that guest spot that week. It made me miss girls’ night and your ex coming to California to force you back home with him.”
“So he never met all of you?” Jeremy asked.
They all said no.
“The only people who hate me are Tom’s ex-wives,” Helena said.
“Have any of them met your friends?” I asked.
Helena thought about it.
Pat said, “I met one of them when she brought over her sons to see Tom.”
“Todd’s fourteen and Ricky’s twelve,” Helena said. “They’re actually good kids. Their mom is never going to like me, but we’re all trying. Kiley is more excited about being a big brother than Todd is, because he got to do it already, but we’re talking about having the older boys stay with us while their mom goes to Europe with her new boyfriend.”
“We were there one weekend when they were visiting,” Susannah said, and laughed. “I thought the older boy was going to have a stroke when he saw Nina and me in bikinis by the pool.”