AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Holiday Pen Pal Twist

Page 33

by Becca Fall

6

CASSIE

The first exhibit in the case for P0X547TY becoming a Christmas person had been left on the edge of the kitchen counter, wrapped in a neat square of parchment paper and tied with red string I’d found in the junk drawer after digging past three dead batteries and a takeout menu from a place that no longer existed.

A gingerbread square, still faintly warm, with a tiny paper tag attached to the string that read P0X547TY. I had messaged him with instructions on where to find it and went on with my day.

P0X547TY’s response came later that morning.

P0X547TY

Exhibit A has been located. The court finds the evidence compelling but not yet conclusive. The defense reserves the right to remain skeptical about becoming a Christmas person.

SmilingsMyFavorite

The prosecution accepts those terms. There will be further exhibits to change your mind.

P0X547TY

It was a very good gingerbread square, btw.

SmilingsMyFavorite

The record will reflect that.

This had become the texture of my mornings. Wake up, whip up some kind of baked good, and leave it in the same place for him to find. It was a simple routine, but it added a small brightness to the start of my day.

Since P0X547TY had made it clear he wasn’t a big sweets person, I had to get a little creative.

Exhibit B had been a small bag of spiced nuts. Exhibit C was two shortbread fingers tucked into an envelope labeled “legal correspondence”. Exhibit D was a slice of cardamom cake.

Each one got a response from P0X547TY. The spiced nuts were “very Christmasy in a way that the defense is willing to acknowledge.” The shortbread was “a strong exhibit, possibly the strongest so far.” The cardamom cake produced a message that simply said: “Damn. This is good.”

He started asking what I was baking next, so I told him, and then I told him why, which turned into me explaining things I didn’t usually say out loud—why brown butter mattered, what actually happened when you creamed butter and sugar, how you were building air into something that would hold everything else up later.

One night, I was sitting at the kitchen table with my laptop open to the bakery folder and a mug of tea beside me when the message came.

P0X547TY

Can I ask you something that isn’t about the case for becoming a Christmas person?

SmilingsMyFavorite

You can ask me anything.

For some damn reason, I meant that.

P0X547TY

All your exhibits are baked goods. You’re so passionate about baking, and I love seeing that spark. It seems like more than a hobby to you. Is it?

The bakery folder was still open on my laptop, the cursor blinking halfway down page three of my business plan, right next to projected first-year revenue numbers.

I typed for a while. Then I deleted it. Then I typed again.

SmilingsMyFavorite

I want to open a bakery. I’ve wanted it for a few years, long enough that I have a savings account and a business plan and three logo concepts I made in the middle of the night and have never shown anyone.