AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Holiday Pen Pal Twist

Page 38

by Becca Fall

Her jaw dropped. “No. Way.”

“I woke up before I, you know, but…” I shut my eyes forcefully. “It was really good.”

“Now you need to have sex with him in real life,” Priya said. “You know, for science.”

“Science?”

“I mean, I’m a scientist.” We laughed, and she added, “But it doesn’t take a scientist to figure out that your pen pal could be Alex.”

“He is not Alex.”

“We don’t know that,” she said mildly.

I straightened, pushing off the counter as the conversation shifted into something more active.

“Alex may have signed up for the book, but there’s no way he’s actually taking the time to send messages. He probably hasn’t even opened the app since he made his profile.” I rolled my eyes at the thought. “Besides, he argues with me about everything,”

“Yes,” she said. “Because he likes talking to you. All the time.”

“That’s not the same thing.”

“It kind of is.”

“It’s really not,” I insisted. “Also, my pen pal is nice.”

“Alex helped you wrap up your Christmas tree.” She pointed to the center of our apartment, where the new tree stood in all its glory.

“That was a coincidence.”

“He stayed late to help you clean up the cookie mess.”

“He broke all the cookies.”

“You broke all the cookies.”

“We broke them together,” I corrected, then stopped again because I was getting off track here. “He doesn’t sound like Alex,” I said, and that, at least, felt true. “He’s softer. More open. Alex is⁠—”

“A little guarded,” Priya finished.

“Yes, but in a different way.”

“In a way that might not show up the same when he’s anonymous?”

I stared at her.

She stared back, completely unbothered.

“I’m going to go for a walk,” I said finally.

“Good idea,” Priya said, her voice warm again, like she had nudged something into motion and was content to let it unfold. “Take your phone. Don’t want to miss any messages from your secret pen pal.”

I didn’t dignify that with a response, but I grabbed my coat anyway, along with my hat, my mittens, and a scarf with small, embroidered snowflakes.

The air outside was sharp and bright, and I walked four blocks before I let myself think about what Priya had said.

I liked P0X547TY.

That part was clear now. It wasn’t just the messages or the jokes or the running legal bit. It was the way he paid attention, the way he responded like what I said mattered, and the way he made things feel possible.