AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Holiday Pen Pal Twist

Page 41

by Becca Fall

“I know,” she said quietly.

She leaned against the partition between my desk and Ben’s, crossing one ankle over the other.

Her lipstick was red today. Cherry red.

My gaze lingered on her mouth for half a second too long, and an entirely unhelpful thought slipped in.

What would happen if I touched it?

If I brushed my thumb across her lower lip, would the color smear?

Would it survive a kiss?

Would she lift her face toward mine, or would she grab my tie and pull me down to meet her?

The image arrived all at once, startling in its clarity.

Cassie standing between my knees. One of my hands at her waist, the other cupping her cheek. Her back pressed lightly against the edge of my desk, that perfect red lipstick softened at the corners.

Heat crawled up my neck, and I tried so hard to focus.

Unfortunately, she was still standing there, looking the same, and the problem with vivid imaginations was that they didn’t disappear nearly as quickly as they arrived.

“Can I ask you something?” she asked.

I dragged myself back to reality.

“You’re going to regardless.”

Her mouth twitched. “Are you excited for the holiday party?”

“Excited is a strong word.”

She laughed under her breath. “Okay, fine. Are you looking forward to the app reveal? Finding out who your pen pal is?”

I kept my attention on the screen in front of me even though the tiny details of Cassie threatened to overwhelm me: the peppermint scent of her coffee, the quiet tap of her nails against the cubicle wall, the way she watched people when she genuinely cared about the answer.

This conversation felt like standing on ice you already knew was too thin. The smart thing to do was walk back toward the shore.

“It’ll be interesting to see how the matching algorithm performed,” I said.

“That’s a very you answer.” Her eyes softened, turning thoughtful. “I’m nervous about mine.”

That got my attention.

For the first time since she’d walked over, I looked up at her properly.

“Why?”

She hesitated. Cassie almost never hesitated.

“I think…” She tucked a curl behind her ear. “Because whoever it is already knows more about me than most people here do.”

Oh.

“He’s pretty cool,” she continued, her smile turning shy around the edges. “Way funnier than I expected. I’ve been trying not to think too hard about it, but the party’s tomorrow and…” She trailed off, looking somewhere over my shoulder. “Sorry. Overshare.”

“It’s not an overshare,” I said, and meant it more than the words could carry.