AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Holiday Pen Pal Twist

Page 57

by Becca Fall

We stayed in the apartment for the morning. She took over my kitchen with easy authority, using the last of my butter and measuring cinnamon in her palm like she trusted herself more than any recipe. I sat at the counter and watched, which was quickly becoming one of my favorite ways to spend time. Every time I stood to help, she waved me off without looking up.

“You’ll slow me down,” she said, already moving on to the next step.

While cooking, Cassie belted all the lyrics to an entire Christmas playlist—something about Mariah Carey defrosting?—and I jumped in where I could.

“This might be the last time I get to bake just for us for a while,” she said as she flipped the bread in the pan.

I paused, halfway to the cabinet. “What do you mean?”

She concentrated on slicing a basket of strawberries. “I’m going to be doing a local pop-up for New Year’s Eve. After, the plan is to open the bakery in February, which means I will be nonstop prepping for that in January.”

“Ah.” I set the plates down beside her, adding the silverware next. “What if I go to the bakery every day and buy all your stock?”

“Then you’ll need to run a lot of laps after boxing to make up for all the sugar you’ll be consuming.”

I slid back into the chair. “Worth it.”

A few minutes later, we sat side by side at the counter, our thighs pressed together, plates balanced between us. I took a bite of the berry French toast and tried to hold in a groan.

“That’s—” I shook my head and went in for another bite before finishing the sentence. “That’s good.”

Cassie giggled as she cut her toast into neat little squares. “Thank you.”

“I meant to tell you that on the first of the month,” I said. “I ate both of the snickerdoodle cookies because they were more than fine; they were fucking good.”

She froze mid-cut, then slammed her palms onto the counter. “You were the one who took the last snickerdoodle?”

I nodded, completely unrepentant.

“I should have known,” she said, narrowing her eyes at me in a way that had no real heat in it. “I thought maybe you didn’t like them.”

“Everything you make is amazing,” I said. “But what I like most about it is that you’re the one who made them. What makes it amazing isn’t the sugar or butter or whatever; it’s the fact that it’s made by you.”

“Can I get that in writing?”

I laughed and finished up my plate in just a few more bites.

“Did you not have plans for Christmas?” I asked. “With the amount of love you have for the holiday, I would have thought you’d be following a color-coded itinerary right now.”

Cassie shook her head. “No plans, unless you count rewatching holiday movies and eating chocolate. What about you?”

“Nothing planned.” I stood, gathering our plates and bringing them to the sink. “I usually keep it quiet.”

“So this is a pleasant surprise for both of us.”

I rinsed my hands, dried them, and stepped back toward her, the ease of the moment settling somewhere deep in my chest like something I hadn’t realized I’d been missing.

“Very pleasant,” I said.

Then I leaned down and planted a kiss against her hair, letting it linger just long enough that it stopped feeling accidental.

I’d come a long way from dreading Christmas each year.

Now it didn’t feel like something to get through.

It felt like something I might look forward to because every year after this would look a little more like this one, and a lot more like her.

In the afternoon, we took a walk.