Page 58
Everyone else is slower to answer. There’s a fun bit of analysis in this game. I don’t know if Jules did make it up or if she learned it from someone else, but as far as icebreakers go, it’s a good one.
“I think it’s true,” I say. Then I wink at Campbell. “Sorry.”
In the end, everyone else sides with me.
Theo winces. “Sorry, bud. It’s true.”
Campbell looks incensed. “Your rooster is named Sir Rise and Shine.”
Shaye looks so pleased with herself. “Yep. That’s his name. But it’s not what Theo calls him.”
“By the rules of the game, Campbell picks third,” Jules pronounces gravely, cutting off his protest. “Theo! You’re next.”
Theo makes up a great lie about Rory and a science fair that Shaye falls for, but everyone else calls out, so Shaye will pick fourth. Rory shares a truth about Garrett that sounds like a lie, and Mom says it can’t possibly be the truth. Dad falls next, then Garrett and Rory. There are a few rounds where Theo, Nate, and I all agree on what’s a lie and what’s a truth, and then Theo thinks that Garrett is lying when he says that Rory thinks a Pop-Tart is a complete meal.
“But you’re a doctor,” he protests.
Rory shrugs shamelessly. “It’s the perfect lunch.”
Which leaves me facing off against Nate for the ultimate Yankee Swap gift picking position. I want to just give it to him, to prove that there are no hard feelings, that I’m gracious at the end of our marriage, as we move into friendship where we both date and move on with our lives.
“Ben, your turn to say a truth or a lie about someone,” Jules instructs crisply. Mom found her a whiteboard, and she’s written everyone’s name on it. On one side, their order for picking gifts later. On the other, who they told a fact about.
He crosses his arms over his thick chest, then lifts one hand and scratches his red beard. Killing time, clearly.
I smother a laugh.
“Ben!” She snaps her fingers. “Popcorn.”
“What? I’ve already been eliminated. Is there another punishment you’re going to make up?”
She sticks her tongue out at him.
He gives me a slow smile. “I can’t make it a lie about Cassie, can I?”
“No. She’s one of the people left!”
“Too bad. I know her better than anyone else here.”
Nate, who had been leaning against the sink, stands up straight.
“Rude,” Rory says calmly. “I’ve known her longer than anyone else here. Not counting you, Mom.”
“Thank you for remembering me.”
Ben flicks his attention to Jules, then to Shaye, before settling on Garrett. “Garrett’s afraid of needles.”
My mom bursts into laughter, which makes Jules start giggling. My dad turns bright red, and Rory rolls her eyes to the ceiling.
Garrett just grins slowly.
“Lie,” I say under the din.
Last Christmas, Garrett ordered Rory a very private gift, an anatomically accurate copy of his pierced penis, and it accidentally found its way under the tree. Rory was mortified when she opened it, but the rest of us found it very amusing. And Garrett handled it with as much grace as anyone possibly could after one’s family had all handled a vibrating facsimile of one’s junk.
Everyone in my family now knows that Garrett is definitely not afraid of needles. But by that point, I was so mad at Nate that I didn’t tell him, and I don’t think anyone else let it slip to the wider gossip mill.
I never told Ben, either, and he rightly looks confused.