Page 166
“I liked the work, which is considerably less convenient.” I watch the wine climb the sides of the glass. “Leaving would be much easier if Xander had managed to make me hate everything about Redemption Records.”
Willow’s expression softens. “Because then you wouldn’t be giving up anything you still wanted.”
“Exactly.”
I nod and look around Bennett’s, carefully avoiding the corner booth where Adam once made me laugh.
This town has become crowded with them. Their music plays in stores, people at Hawthorne House mention them without knowing I’m trying to forget how it felt to be part of their lives, and even this bar reminds me of nights when I was still convincing myself I could keep everything professional.
“If I stay, I’m going to see them eventually,” I say. “Maybe next month, maybe six months from now, but they’ll come home.”
Willow rests her elbows against the table. “Would seeing them be worse than leaving us all?”
“I wish I knew.”
She waits, watching me over the rim of her glass.
“I miss them so much that I keep looking at my phone whenever it vibrates.” I take another drink, although the wine isn’t helping nearly as much as advertised. “I drove through town yesterday and heard one of their songs, and I nearly missed a turn trying to shut it off.”
Willow reaches across the table and covers my hand. “You’ve been trying very hard to treat this like another work problem.”
“Work problems are easier.” I reach for a fry and break it between my fingers. “They usually come with schedules and spreadsheets.”
Willow takes another drink, watching me over the rim of her glass. “I can see why emotions have been such a disappointment to you.”
A laugh escapes me despite myself. “They’re appallingly disorganized.”
Her teasing is gentle enough that I manage a smile, but it disappears when I look toward the booth again.
“I fell in love with them.”
Willow’s fingers tighten around mine.
I’ve already said the words to her once, when I arrived at Hawthorne House barely capable of getting through a sentence without crying, but they feel different now. Then, admitting I loved them felt like explaining why losing them hurt this much.
Tonight, it feels like admitting what I still want.
“All three of them,” I say. “I kept blaming the tour for making everything feel bigger because we were together constantly, but that stopped being believable a long time ago.”
Willow gives me time to continue.
“I wanted the life we were building together.” I trace my fingertip through the condensation on my glass. “I still do.”
Willow’s eyes shine, although she smiles. “You know I’m probably the least likely person in Redemption Falls to think loving three men is a problem.”
“I considered that before confessing.”
“Very strategic.”
“I try.” My smile disappears as I look down at our joined hands. “I thought they loved me too.”
Willow rubs her thumb across my knuckles. “I think they do.”
“They haven’t reached out.”
“You all got hurt, and everyone reacted from that place.” She leans closer across the table. “You can believe they handled it badly without deciding that everything before it meant nothing.”
I stare at our joined hands. “I don’t know whether I could forgive them for how they reacted.”