Page 14
“And a background on Gill,” Miles said. “Employment history, any public records that would have made him identifiable as a target consistent with the Elementalist profile. We need to understand how he was selected.”
“That’s already started,” Solis said. “I put someone on it last night when the initial scene report went out. I’ve even got a few uniforms asking around to family and friends.”
Miles looked at the iPad one more time, at the wire photographs and the shallow burn sites and the slightly irregular loop ends that a non-specialist would never have caught. He thought about the gap between almost right and exactly right, and what that gap might mean.
“All right,” he said, handing the iPad back to Solis. “Let's get back to the field office and start on the access logs.”
The three of them moved back across the gravel toward the barrier tape. The heat had intensified in the fifteen minutes they had been standing at the scene. Because he’d already started to sweat, the walk back to the car felt longer than it had on the way in. Miles got into the passenger seat and Vic started the engine. The air conditioner churned but even that air was hot for the first few moments.
Through the windshield, the desert stretched out ahead of them, enormous and pale and giving nothing away.
CHAPTER ELEVEN
Vic had taken over the small desk in the corner of her hotel room and turned it into a workspace. Her laptop was open, her phone was charging beside it, and she had a second browser window running on her tablet propped against the wall. The air conditioning was working hard against the Tucson evening, and it was just barely winning.
Miles had gone directly to the field office from the overlook to work with Solis on the access logs. Vic had split off to work the phone, which suited her. The access log was a document problem, and Miles was better at those. The source problem was a people problem, and that was more her territory. Plus, she could do without the monotonous gloom of another FBI conference room.
She had started with the full list of names Solis pulled from the evidence access system. It was longer than she had hoped. In the six days since the Caswell arrest, a sizable list of people had accessed the warehouse evidence file or the forensic photography package, or both. Among them were eleven field agents from the Tucson office, four forensic technicians, two members of the federal prosecution team, one court reporter who had been present for Caswell's initial appearance, two federal public defenders assigned to the case, and three journalists who had been granted limited press briefings.
She had worked through the field agents and forensic techs first, cross-referencing each name against the task force's internal personnel flags. Nothing came back. When necessary, she hopped on the phone, called them and asked for specifics as to their reason for accessing the materials. The prosecution team was clean on a first pass. The court reporter had been present for a sealed proceeding and had no documented connection to any press outlet or public platform. The public defenders were a harder call because their professional obligation required access to the materials, which made any leak from that direction both plausible and nearly impossible to prove without something more concrete than circumstantial timing.
That left the journalists. And quite honestly, this was the part she had dreaded. She had nothing against journalists per se, but she knew they could be a handful. Some got defensive at the drop of a hat.
The press briefings had been managed by the field office's public affairs coordinator, and the documentation on them was specific. Each journalist had been given a controlled summary of the arrest: the abduction charge, Paula Oñate's survival and recovery, and Caswell's background as a former electrical contractor. The forensic specifics, including the wire technique and the burn site placement, had been explicitly excluded from all three briefings.
Vic had the briefing outlines in front of her and had read them twice. There was nothing in the approved materials that would have given a journalist the information that had subsequently appeared in public.
She had searched all three journalists within the first hour. Two of them wrote for established outlets and had clean professional histories with no obvious connection to the task force's prior cases.
But the third was different. Very different. Her name was Connie Marsh. She was based in Phoenix and described herself in her social media profiles as an independent journalist and true-crime researcher. She had a YouTube channel with 240,000 subscribers, a TikTok account with considerably more, and an active presence on several true-crime forums. This included a Reddit thread dedicated specifically to the Elementalist cases, where Marsh was extremely active. The thread had over sixty thousand members.
Vic had found it easily and had been scrolling through it for the past forty minutes. The posts ranged from the earnest to the genuinely disturbing. There were members who had built elaborate theory boards tracking every confirmed Elementalist case, cross-referencing victim profiles and geographic patterns with the kind of obsessive detail that made Vic uncomfortable—not because it was wrong but because some of it was so correct that it alarmed her just how public some of this information was.
There were posts speculating about Kane's identity, suggesting he had various false aliases or that more than one person was actually Kane, and there was some sort of villainous team at work. There were members who had created what they called tribute posts for the victims that were framed in language that made the victims sound like characters in a story rather than people who had died. One thread, pinned at the top of the forum with over two thousand comments, was titled “The Copper Conductor: Everything We Know” and had been updated within the past twelve hours.
Vic read through it carefully, a little sickened by how this killer had captured the minds and the imaginations of so many people.
Most of it was inference and speculation built on press coverage. But approximately two-thirds of the way down the post, there was a section under the subheading “Method” that stopped her. She read it once quickly and then again slowly, and then she opened the notes application on her phone and typed out three sentences from it verbatim.
The first: the wire used in the Caswell arrest was medium-gauge copper, wrapped in a specific overlapping pattern and finished with a loop closure at both ends. The second: the technique is consistent with electrical work applications, suggesting the perpetrator had professional training in wire handling. The third: burn sites documented at the scene were placed at vascular proximity points on the forearms and hands, consistent with a deliberate effort to mark sites of electrical conductivity.
Vic sat back and looked at what she had typed.
The loop closure detail had not been in any press coverage. The burn site placement and the vascular proximity framing had not been in any press coverage. The overlapping pattern description had not been in any press coverage. She had the full press briefing outlines open in another window and she checked each detail against them one more time to be certain. None of the three sentences she had transcribed corresponded to anything in the approved briefing materials.
She scrolled back up to the top of the post and found the attribution line. The method section had been contributed and verified by a user whose handle linked directly to Connie Marsh's Reddit profile.
Vic checked the timestamp on the post. It had been updated at 6:47 in the morning, one day after the Caswell arrest. The press conference had taken place the afternoon before.
She pulled up Marsh's YouTube channel and found the video Marsh had posted the evening of the press conference. It had been uploaded within thirty minutes of Hayes closing the podium. The video was fourteen minutes long and Vic watched all of it. Marsh was articulate and well-prepared, and the first two-thirds of the video covered the arrest in terms consistent with what had been said publicly, with portions of the conference spliced in…including the segment where Miles was taking questions. But in the final section, Marsh leaned into the camera and said she had been able to confirm through a source close to the investigation that the copper wire method used in the Caswell case was considerably closer linked to the Elementalist cases than the bureau had indicated publicly.
Vic closed the video and sat for a moment, not liking the way this whole bit of the puzzle made her feel. Then she picked up her phone and called Miles.
He answered on the second ring. “How are you doing?”
“I've got something,” she said. “There's a journalist named Connie Marsh. And I use the term journalist loosely. She was at the press conference, she got a press briefing, and she posted a video that evening. She also updated a Reddit thread the following morning. Both of them contain forensic details that were not in the approved briefing materials and were not discussed at the conference.”
“How specific are we talking?”