AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Merry Misconduct

Page 59

by Katie Bailey

“That from the movie?” I guess.

Her blush deepens. “Apparently…I’ve never actually seen it.”

“Can you believe that?” Reagan clasps a hand to her chest. “She didn’t know she was coming until the last second, so I recommended an easy last minute costume, seeing as Cae didn’t have anything with shoulder pads in her closet.”

“Thank goodness for that,” I say, both happy she’s here and curious what made her come when she hadn’t been planning to.

I’m rewarded with a laugh from Caelin. “Luckily for me, the closest costume shop to my house had wings.” She adjusts one elastic strap and I see a red mark from where they’re cutting into her shoulder. “Unluckily, they’re meant to be for a child’s costume.”

The jazz band strikes up a rendition of “White Christmas,” and an elderly couple stand and begin to sway. Reagan’s eyes light up. “I’ll be right back,” she says, pulling her phone out as she rushes to capture the moment for socials.

I turn to Caelin. “For the record, I’ve never seen It’s a Wonderful Life either.”

“Phew, I was beginning to think I was the only one. Everyone was hardcore judging me.”

“We should watch it sometime,” I say. “Just to find out what all the fuss is about and escape all the judgmentalness, of course.”

“Maybe next Christmas, for our one year wedding anniversary.” Her eyes spark as she looks at me. “And for the record, I believe in presents for anniversaries. No paper or clocks or whatever they say, but real presents.”

“Like jewelry?”

“As long as it’s really blingy and ostentatious.”

I look down at the stacks of colorful beaded bracelets on her arms and chuckle. “I’ll make a note you only wear Tiffany and Cartier.”

“My style exactly.” A shadow of a smile moves over her face. “You’re a fast learner; this marriage will be a breeze.”

“Only because I’m low-key obsessed with you.” I hold my hands up. “Your words, not mine.”

True words, too.

“I think Robbie was on to us yesterday, by the way.” Caelin takes a sip of her cocoa, frowning. “He knew who you were, so he had some doubts. I spun a story of my own to him on the way out in a last ditch attempt to sell our epic love.”

I wince. Once again, I acted on impulse without weighing up the potential outcomes. And once again, my damned reputation turned out to be two steps ahead of me.

“Do you think I took it too far with all that?”

“No. I think you were right.” She peeks up at me, and I look at her in surprise.

“I’m sorry, I think I just hallucinated. Did you just say I was right?”

“Don’t let it go to your head, but yes. I think Maria would have never gone for it if we hadn’t put on that show.” She giggles, but then her expression sobers, her fingers tightening around the mug in her hands. “That was quite the story you came up with, by the way. About being on a date with another woman who ditched you for another guy that night.”

“That was all true.” I raise my brows at her. “I was super late because I had to volunteer here first, and by the time I arrived at Candy Cane Kiss, my date thought I’d ditched her and was busy making out with Perez.”

Caelin sputters a laugh, then searches my expression and stills. “Wait, you’re serious?”

“Yes. I escaped to the rooftop shortly after.”

Her mouth twists in surprise as she adjusts the strap of one of her wings again. The red mark is still there, darker now.

“You know, I think I might have met her that night.” She chuckles softly as she looks over to where Colton’s sitting with some residents. “Your intended date. She had a guy with her who was covered in lipstick, and now that I think about it, it could have been Colton she was with.”

I nod, my gaze still focused on her shoulder. “That checks out.”

“Awh, poor Dallas,” she teases, then grins. “If it helps, when I met your date she was nice to me because I’d just seen my ex on the dance floor with his girlfriend—the same girl he cheated on me with.”

Her tone is flippant, her demeanor relaxed, but there’s a tightness in her eyes I don’t miss as I stare at her, processing what she’s just told me. Whoever this guy was, he obviously meant something to her, and he hurt her. And I kind of want to hurt him for it.