Page 7
My steering seems to work, because she purses her lips, as if pinching back a smile. “Athletics? Are you a gym teacher?”
“I wish.”
She giggles. “Why’s that?”
“Because an English teacher and a gym teacher meeting on a rooftop sounds like the beginning of an epic love story.” I wait in anticipation for her to call me out again on using an awful line, looking forward to what her next little barb might be.
But she surprises me yet again by nodding, playing along. “I’d teach you to conjugate those pesky verbs we were talking about earlier, and you’d help me learn how to catch a ball. Because obviously, for the purposes of this story, I’m hopelessly uncoordinated.”
“Wouldn’t be a Hallmark-level romance otherwise,” I agree. My sister loved those movies growing up. I’ve seen hundreds of them, so I know how the story always goes. “Of course, we’d be working at the same high school. I’d bring you coffee between classes, and you’d get mad at me for failing all the kids who couldn’t climb the rope.”
She pushes herself up from where she was leaning on the railing, stands to her full—tiny compared to me—height, and plants her hands on her hips. “You’d make innocent children do that barbaric exercise?”
“Yes, and then you’d walk into the gym one day and see me torturing the kids with rope climbs, and my caveman-like teaching tactics would lead to your eventual grounds for divorce.”
“Oh, I thought that was when I caught you making out with the substitute teacher in the supply closet,” she replies without missing a beat.
“She meant nothing to me!”
“So you keep saying.”
“I just want one more chance, though I don’t deserve it,” I say, enjoying myself more than I have in a long time.
“I’m not usually one for giving second chances, but maybe our high school love story is worth saving yet.”
“My redemption arc will be worth it; I’ll put a million roses in your classroom. White, not red, so we don’t invoke any further Texas Chainsaw Massacre vibes.”
“Good. But for the record, I prefer peonies.” As she says this, she shivers a little. Glances at the door that would take her back downstairs.
I’m genuinely enjoying our conversation. Her humor and sass. This is the sort of girl you take home to meet your mama. The sort of girl you want to know more about, for no other reason than to watch her light up when she talks about the things she loves. I don’t want to say goodbye to her just yet. I don’t even know her name.
“Did you want to go downstairs and check if your friend has arrived. I could help you look for…him?”
Yes, I’m fishing. Sue me.
“Her. But you already knew that, didn’t you?”
“I did,” I admit.
“Not as smooth as you think you are with those lines, huh?”
“Not with you."
Her lips twitch like she’s struggling to hide her smile. Man, she’s pretty. “Awh. Do I make you nervous, Daddy?” She pulls a face. “Ew, I can’t say that even as a joke.”
“Just call me Father Christmas, then.”
She snorts with laughter. Then, after a beat, she says, “My friend’s coming with a bunch of other people. If she has arrived, she won’t miss me for a bit.”
“You’re not worried about the sweaty dudes hitting on her?”
“She’s with a bunch of sweaty dude types.” Her eyes flicker to the door again, and something passes over her expression that makes me think there’s a lot more to her bad night than her friend being late. She blows out a breath. “Do you want to go back down, though?”
I don’t. And I can tell this is what she needs more at this moment. To escape whatever it is that’s troubling her for a little longer. And I want the same. I want to stay up here with her and not be the Dallas Cooper everyone expects me to be, but to just be for a while.
So I lift a shoulder as I say, “I'd rather stay here and ask you all about backpacking in Asia.”
“You really want to hear about that?” She looks skeptical.