Page 89
My stomach twists for an entirely different reason. The one person I need to talk to. The one person I’m not sure will ever want to.
Logan waggles the waiver. “So. You in?”
I stare at them. I stare at the form.
If I say no, I’m the uptight asshole who doesn’t mesh with the team. If I say yes, I’m a consenting participant in pain and humiliation—an experience which, honestly, isn’t that different from being emotionally invested in Whitney Shields while actively lying by omission.
“Fine,” I mutter, snatching the form. “But if I die, put on my headstone that I was coerced.”
Charlie claps my back. “Love the spirit. Bonding day at three. Don’t be late. Bring water.”
I blink. “Why would I need water—”
But they’re already walking away, laughing like criminals.
I came to Coral Cove to swim, keep my head down, apologize to Rory, and not ruin anyone’s life.
Instead, I’m kissing a girl I’m not being fully honest with, getting haunted by a man who thinks he still has access to my worst moments, and apparently about to let Logan and Charlie make decisions about my body hair.
I jam my feet into my slides and head for the recovery room anyway.
An ice bath is exactly the kind of jarring sensation I need to drag my brain back into my body—back into the present—back into the version of me that’s trying to do things differently.
Because the other version?
The one Nico wants?
The one the internet loves?
He’s still in there.
And after last night, I’m not sure how long I can keep him from messing everything up.
seventeen
. . .
WHITNEY
Winnie’s bathroom has turned into a full-scale glam operation.
Curling irons are heating up on the counter. Dani’s makeup bag is spread open like a display case. Ren is perched on the closed toilet lid, applying eyeliner with the calm precision of someone who has never once stabbed herself in the eye. Winnie moves around the room in her usual competent way—half dressed, half accessorized, somehow still in charge.
And I’m standing in front of the mirror trying to pretend my mouth doesn’t still remember the taste of Connor’s.
Because it does.
It’s been less than twenty-four hours, and my body keeps replaying the kiss like it’s a highlight reel I can’t turn off. The way he kissed me back—no hesitation, no polite testing. The way his hands locked onto my waist like he’d been holding himself back all night and finally stopped trying. The way I ended up on his lap like it was unavoidable.
Then the way he went rigid.
Like something pulled him out of the moment so fast I barely caught my breath.
Then he left, and I haven’t heard from him since.
So, yeah. I’m fine. Great. Totally normal.
Dani snaps her compact shut and squints at me. “Okay. What’s going on with you?”