Page 13
Then another.
Then a soft, wandering melody begins to take shape.
I turn toward the inviting sound, and that’s when I see him.
Sitting at the upright piano near the back wall—the one that usually collects dust between drunk attempts at “Sweet Caroline,” there’s a man in a black henley that clings in a way that should be illegal. His dark, wavy hair is a mess of deliberate carelessness, like he ran his hands through it once and called it a day. And when he glances up briefly at the room, a crooked smile tugs at his mouth like he knows a secret.
He pauses a moment to crack his knuckles exaggeratedly, then starts playing “Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas.”
Not perfectly, but warmly, and the bar quiets to listen.
The ornaments overhead sway with the subtle shift in sound. Conversations fade, and a couple near the tree leans closer together.
And then, he starts to sing. It’s soft, but a little rough.
The hint of a British accent curling around the words like it doesn’t quite fit but also somehow fits perfectly.
Something inside my chest releases because this is my favorite holiday song.
The one I play when I bake at midnight. The one I hum when Oliver’s half-asleep on my shoulder. The one that always makes me feel like the world could be okay again if I just let it.
Rick exhales sharply beside me.
“Oh my god,” he mutters. “Is he serious?”
I don’t bother answering because my eyes are glued to the piano, and the man playing it.
He keeps playing like the room belongs to him—not in an arrogant way. In a this is mine to share kind of way.
When he reaches the last line, the entire bar has gone quiet.
He finishes on a soft, imperfect note. And for one full second, nobody moves.
Then the room erupts into applause.
“That was off-key,” Rick says. “And not exactly optimized for the room’s acoustics.”
Something in me stills and I turn to him slowly.
“You didn’t like it?”
He shrugs. “It’s sentimental content. Low conversion value.”
Low conversion value?
I blink, then set my glass down gently.
“So I think this is where our date ends.”
Rick jolts back, clearly affronted. “What? Because I didn’t like the song?”
“No,” I say calmly. “Because I need a man who enjoys small, imperfect things that make people feel something. Not someone who critiques joy like he’s analyzing a quarterly budget.”
He scoffs. “That guy just wants attention.”
“Maybe.” I slide off my stool. “But at least he knows how to share it.”
Rick opens his mouth again, but I don’t stay to hear what comes out. As I move through the crowd, the pianist looks up, catches my eye, and smiles. It’s not cocky or smug, but it’s like he knew exactly why I stood up.