Page 59
He grins. “Good. I want to see you in it.”
I practically sprint down the hall before my heart launches out of my chest. In my bedroom, I strip out of my cookie-scented clothes and pull on the pink dress. It slides on like a dream. Short skirt, fitted bodice, soft fake fur trim—it’s pure Christmas whimsy and just a hint of flirty. The thigh-high socks and little red shoes complete it. When I add the hat, I barely recognize myself.
I’m used to being the woman who shows up with the cookies, not the one who gets dressed up to match someone.
When I walk back into the living room, Beck’s helping Maddie and Oliver set up a game. From the coffee table, he looks up and goes absolutely still.
Then his eyes slowly drag over me, from the hat to the shoes, and something deep and warm flickers there.
“Holy…” His voice drops an octave. “Lottie.”
I tug self-consciously at the skirt. “Do I look ridiculous?”
“No.” He walks over to me, gaze earnest and molten. “You look like every fantasy Buddy ever had.”
My face flames and the room tilts a bit.
He lifts one hand as if he wants to touch me, then hesitates. I step closer, giving him permission without saying a word. His fingers brush the edge of the skirt.
“I picked right,” he murmurs.
Jesus. I can barely breathe.
He cracks a smile. “My tights are going to be an even bigger issue with you looking like that tonight.”
I groan. “Oh god.”
Beck laughs but then slips his arm through mine. “Ready to absolutely dominate this theme party?”
My heart flips again.
“Yeah,” I say softly. “Let’s go.”
After we say goodnight to Oliver, we step outside together into the cold, the snow catching in the fleece trim of my dress. Beck looks down at me, still grinning in full Buddy mode, and I cling to his arm, warm from his coat, and from something else I probably shouldn’t name.
I’ve never walked into this party with anyone before.
This night has always been another thing to survive alone—show up, smile, manage the questions, dodge the pity, pretend I’m fine with being the only one arriving without someone beside her. But tonight, Beck is here and matching me. Choosing to walk in at my side like it’s the easiest thing in the world. And that’s the dangerous part. Because Beck makes all of it feel easy. Like maybe walking into a room with someone beside me could become normal if I let it. And I don’t know what to do with that.
Walking into Brielle and Brad’s house on Beck’s arm feels like stepping into some alternate universe—one where I’m not the single mom showing up solo with cookies, but part of an actual couple in matching costumes.
Everyone loses their minds the second they see us.
“Buddy and Jovie!”
“You two win.”
“Absolutely iconic.”
“Brad, look at Beck’s tights!”
It’s laughter and glitter and holiday chaos, and Beck somehow gets even brighter in the middle of it. He keeps his arm looped through mine at first, steadying me as we move through the crowd. He’s charming and easy and ridiculously handsome in a way that should not be legal in yellow spandex. And god help me, I love it.
I love how natural it feels. How he stays close without crowding me. How he keeps checking in with one quick look like he wants to make sure I’m okay.
Every so often he leans in to murmur something just for me.
“Your hat’s crooked, love.”