AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Now We’re Even

Page 106

by S.J. Sylvis

“Hated?” he repeats.

I peek at him, and his mouth twitches. The tiniest smile creeps onto my face, but it’s fleeting.

“I could never understand why Chase sought me out. I was the nerdy girl who was constantly scribbling in her notebook during his games.”

“Because you were the sports journalist for the paper?”

“How do you–” I shake my head. “Never mind.”

“Go on,” he says, voice low.

I exhale shakily. “Hockey is really the only sport at Alder that is any good–”

Callahan snickers and then hisses through clenched teeth. I glance at him worriedly, and he shakes his head.

“Anyway…I was always around the hockey players, and they typically just brushed right past me, but then I noticed Chase kept talking to me here and there, flirting with me, inviting me to parties."

“Okay…” Callahan drawls. “Then what happened?”

I lift a shoulder. “I liked the attention. I liked him. He was nice, charming. He noticed me, and the nerdy girls never get noticed.”

“Nora…you walk into a room, and everyone notices you.”

I huff out a laugh. “That is not true.”

Callahan slowly slides down the side of the bed with a pained expression on his face. “Callahan, your ribs!”

His legs spread out beside me, and he grabs the backs of my knees, sliding me against the wood floor until I’m right in front of him. “It is true,” he argues.

My skin heats beneath his hands, but I brush past it. “We started dating. I went to all the hockey parties, got to know his friends. He met my aunt and uncle and was a perfect gentleman.”

A line of confusion creases in between Callahan’s eyebrows.

“Keyword is was. Things started to change. He started to get…pushy.”

Callahan tenses. “Did he push you to do something you didn’t want to do?”

I shake my head. “No. Well…”

“Nora.”

“He didn’t force me to do anything I didn’t want to do. I willingly had sex with him, but I may have felt a little pressured in the beginning.”

A ragged breath brushes against my face. Callahan’s eyes squeeze closed.

“He kept telling me he loved me after we had sex, and I knew he wanted me to say it back…”

“Did you?”

“Say it back?” I look away. “Eventually.”

“No. I mean…did you…love him?”

The back of my throat burns, but I swallow the knot. “I thought I did. But how can you love someone you don’t even know?” My lip trembles as I gaze up to the ceiling, keeping the emotions on hold. “It was all a lie. He started dating me because of some stupid hazing ritual the hockey team had.”

“Wait…what?”

I sigh shakily. “The goal was to get me to fall in love with him, which was why he kept telling me he loved me after we had sex.”