Page 91
“Like what?” Evie asks. “Guess how many times Skye has turned you down when you try to sleep with her?”
I slap my hand over my mouth to keep my laugh at bay.
She turns to Skye, who’s pretending to count on her fingers. “Add tonight too, because you’re not sleeping with him while I’m in the same room.”
Hayes scoffs. “Can’t a guy just be friends with a girl?”
Me, Evie, and Skye all answer at the same time. “No.”
Evie’s blunt haircut brushes her shoulders with the shake of her head. “Honestly, Callahan has a better chance at sleeping with his fake girlfriend than you with Skye. Just give up already.”
I tense against the couch, and Callahan drops his protein shake onto the counter.
Hayes slowly cranes his neck to me and then to Callahan. “Fake girlfriend, you say?”
For the first time since meeting her, Evie’s unmoving features actually shift into remorse. “Sorry,” she whispers.
It could be worse. We could be in a room with someone who actually considers Chase to be a friend. He’s fooled most of Wilder U, even some of Callahan’s teammates, but not Hayes.
“I knew something wasn’t legit about you two…” He wiggles his finger between Callahan and me. “But with that photo circling around from the Puck Off and then earlier at the party…” He looks at us closely. “I was beginning to rethink my assumptions.”
“So you do have thoughts?” Evie asks, eyes steady and unblinking.
Hayes glares at her and then turns back to me and Callahan. “I’m confused.”
“Shocker,” Evie mutters.
I bite the inside of my cheek. I think Evie hates hockey players more than I did.
Do. More than I do.
“What exactly is this?” He gestures between us again.
Callahan wipes his spilled protein shake from the counter. “What do you mean?”
“You two are…what? Fuck buddies and just calling it fake dating?”
I jump from the couch. “We are not fuck buddies.”
“Friends with benefits?” Hayes asks.
“No!” I blurt.
I can’t look over at Callahan, because the second I do, my body will grow warm, and I’ll be forced to remember what we did just a couple of hours ago at a random party.
“My mistake,” Hayes muses, voice laced with humor. “You two put on an awfully good show for two people who aren’t…intimate.”
“Wow.” Evie claps. “What a big word for you.”
“I’m going to get ready for bed,” I say, excusing myself from the “party.”
My pulse races as I rush to the bedroom.
I lock myself in the bathroom and pace over the tiled floor. Tonight was exactly what Hayes described it as. A show.
It’s called method acting. I was simply in character.
That’s it.