AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Until I Found You

Page 124

by Erika Kelly

Decker didn’t think he’d ever seen his dad so worked up. But honestly, he understood. Because every word his dad said stirred the not-so-secret pot where he kept his feelings for her until they were swirling and taking form, making it impossible to contain them.

“Love’s a choice,” his dad said. “Life’ll give you a million reasons to walk away—trust me on that. But when you find the right person, you fight like hell for her. And don’t use Birdie as an excuse. That girl needs Willa every bit as much as you do.”

“You’re giving me words, Dad. But I know the reality of my life, and there’s not a chance in hell I can do my job, give Birdie what she needs, and try to make a long-distance relationship work.”

“You want a game plan, I get it. But there isn’t one. You’re gonna have to make it up as you go along. And ultimately, the things that matter stay, and the things that don’t fall away. But you take a good look at your future, and you figure out what it’ll look like without Willa. If it works for you, then sure, don’t drag her along. But if you can’t stand the idea of not being with her, then you make it work.”

It stirred him up. He wanted to believe what his dad was saying. But his dad didn’t understand the life of a starting quarterback. “Things were a hell of a lot simpler a week ago.”

“Yeah, but were they better?”

Before Willa?

“No.”

“Our experiences are different,” his dad said. “I lost the love of my life, and you might’ve found yours. The only thing I can tell you is, what you do now matters. I learned that with you boys. Thinking I could build a bond with my kids after neglecting them for so long didn’t work.”

“We’re close with you now.”

“Sure. But Jude spent half his life on the road. Alone. Wyatt’s in an Airstream, and Boone’s never had a girlfriend. The wounds of your childhoods made it hard for you boys to trust anyone. And if I had it to do over again, I’d make different choices. I’d make loving my boys my highest priority.”

“And how would you have made a living? We’d never have left the clubhouse.”

“But that’s not your issue, is it? You have enough money to last you ten lifetimes. Again, I can’t tell you what to do. Your situation isn’t mine. I’m only telling you that what you do today matters.”

Birdie’s face flashed in his mind—her arms around his neck, her voice soft against his chest. You got my fifi.

“We don’t know what Birdie’s first three years were like,” his dad continued. “We can’t fix that. But we can influence the rest.”

The words landed right in the center of his chest, causing a seismic shift in his body.

Decker stared at the saltshaker, his fingers going still. The kitchen felt too quiet now, the hum of the refrigerator loud in the space between them, the smell of pie suddenly too sweet.

He drew in a slow, practiced breath, the way he’d been trained to calm himself. Only it didn’t work. Because for the first time, he understood exactly what being her father meant.

And exactly what it was going to cost him.

Chapter Twenty-One

When Decker heard laughter in the stairwell, he got up and grabbed the oven mitts.

The conversation with his dad had wrecked him—fanning hope in the face of an impossible situation was the worst kind of hell—and Willa didn't need to see it.

The door opened, and she and Ava burst in, all bright eyes and big smiles. Willa’s hair was loose, her cheeks flushed from cocktails and a walk across the town square, and she was just so damn pretty, he had to look away.

Though why it mattered at this point, he didn't know. His secret was out: He was crazy about her.

As he pulled the pie from the oven, Willa came up to him.

“That looks delicious.” Her lips were as juicy as if she'd just bitten into a ripe peach, and he wanted to lick them and taste the sweetness. “I saw all the pies downstairs. Do you think we have enough?”

He put the last one of the night into the oven. “We’re short about a hundred, but we’ll see how many we get in the morning.” His gaze darted away. There was no way he could hide this…this vulnerability. His dad had cracked him open, and his feelings were spilling out everywhere.

Some of the cherry filling bubbled over, and she swiped it with a finger. “Ow. Hot.”

“Funny how that happens,” his dad said, joining them at the counter. His gaze snagged on the pie. He went still. “What the hell is that?”

“A pie,” Ava said helpfully. “Looks like cherry. My favorite.”