AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Until I Found You

Page 53

by Erika Kelly

Oh, wait. I won’t be here.

Right.

That shouldn’t have landed so hard, considering leaving had always been the plan.

She swiped a finger in the bowl, licking off the filling. “So, how long have you been doing this pie-baking thing?” Her cheeks sucked in.

Oh, hell. “Since I was a kid.” To keep from imagining his dick in her mouth, he plunged his hands into the dry mixture and kneaded the butter into it.

“Explain.” She sounded almost accusatory, and it made him smile.

“Well, funny enough, it happened during Wild West Days.” Actually, they were coming up on the three-day event that took place every July in Calamity. The whole town was preparing for it. “I got separated from my family during the parade—I must’ve been nine or ten. My dad always said if you get lost, stay put. It was the only way he’d be able to find us, so I parked my ass on a bench in the town square and waited. I was watching all the chaos around me when this woman sat down next to me. She was nice, asking me questions.” He didn’t remember much about her. He hadn’t been very interested in talking to an old lady.

Mostly, he’d been scared. Wild West Days was a huge draw for summer tourists. All about reenacting the past, it had staged shootouts, live concerts, stagecoach rides… It was loud, crowded, and loads of fun—only not so much for a lost kid.

“And she sat with you till your dad found you and bought you a slice of pie?”

“That’s so basic,” he teased. “My story’s way better than that.”

“And you’re anything but basic.”

“Apparently, because she had a gift for me.”

“Really? Was it in the form of candy? Was she missing her puppy?”

He laughed. “Nope.” But his smile faded when he realized something. “You know what’s funny? I’ve never shared this story with anyone before.”

“Because you’d get in trouble for taking candy from a stranger?” She shifted her weight, pressing her hip to the counter.

“No. Because the lady told me not to. She said it was special—that it was just for me.”

“Well, now I’m dying to know what it was.”

“It was a recipe book.”

“You’re telling me some old lady walks around with recipe books and hands them out to little kids?”

“It wasn’t like that. It was handmade.” It had a cloth cover—navy—with flour embedded in the fabric. The spine was broken, so the pages were loose. It was obviously well-used, with its yellowed pages smeared with jam and butter so old it had turned translucent.

It had made him feel special that she’d given him something as well-loved as that.

“That’s so interesting.” She took another swipe of the filling in the metal bowl. “So, after all this time of never telling anyone, why me? Why tonight?” she asked softly, as if afraid to show how much it meant to her.

Which only reinforced his desire to tell her. “Because I trust you.” He pulled the pie out of the oven to sprinkle the crumb for the rest of the bake. She didn’t know how important that was to him. He had very few people in his circle.

When he closed the oven, he came back to clean his mess and found her looking soft and warm. “Thank you.”

It reminded him of the honeymoon suite, the scent of roses, and the feel of their tongues tangling, the press of her restless body against him. The quiet hum of appliances and the low lights casting shadows only drew him deeper into the memory.

He reached for her, his hand cupping her cheek, her silky hair brushing his fingers. Her breathing changed, turned shallow, and her nipples hardened. The heat in her eyes kicked desire into a raging⁠—

A door clicked shut, and a woman shuffled into the kitchen. “Oh. Sorry. Everything okay?”

“Yep.” Willa stepped sideways, away from his touch. “We’re baking a pie.”

“A pie, huh? Well, it sure smells good.” The woman was illuminated by the open refrigerator as she smiled at Willa. “Your dad likes to handle Mrs. Archer’s requests, but I didn’t want to wake him. That man works too hard.”

“Oh, no. What does she want now?” Willa asked.