Page 284
I opened it.
Leah, it began, and I put it down because just my name in his handwriting did something to me I wasn’t ready for.
I never finished reading the first one, and for years I left the others unopened. They remained in a shoebox on the closet floor, behind the coats, behind the shoes, in the same darkness where everything had begun.
I kept the letters. Every single one. I told myself it was evidence, documentation, something to hold on to in case the truth ever needed to come out. But I knew, even then, that wasn’t why I kept them.
I never responded. Not once.
What would I have said?
That I understood why he’d killed my father? That I forgave him for the years of deception? That I still thought about his hands on my skin in the darkness of the cabin and the way he looked at me when he said he loved me?
I didn’t understand. I didn’t forgive.
And God help me, I still thought about him.
Five and a half years.
Five and a half years since they’d pulled me from that basement. Since I’d died and been brought back to life twice. Five since I learned to breathe without pain and walk with no assistance. Since I’d testified against him in a courtroom where he never once looked away from my face.
Five years since I lied on the stand.
The trial lasted nineteen days.
The prosecutor had asked me to recount the night of my father’s murder, trying to tie him and the other to it, and I’d said I couldn’t remember. I’d said the trauma had blocked it out. I’d said a lot of things that weren’t true because the truth would have put Rowan in a cell for the rest of his life, and some part of me, some stupid, broken, twisted, pathetic part, couldn’t bear that.
So I’d told them about my relationship with Ethan. About his controlling behavior. About James. About the basement. About the chain and the flashlight and Lilly’s small face in the dark. I’d told them everything except the thing that changed my life forever.
And Rowan had sat there in his orange jumpsuit, his hands cuffed to the table, watching me with those eyes that had seen everything I was and hadn’t looked away, and he’d never said a word.
They gave him five years.
Five years for what they could prove. For the weapons they found in his car and the silencer on the gun found on the basement floor. For being in the wrong place at the wrong time with the wrong people.
No charge for putting a bullet between Ethan’s eyes.
Self-defense.
No charge for the man’s body discovered in the freezer beyond the white painter’s sheet I had slept beside for weeks, either. Rowan claimed he knew nothing about him. Nothing for the other three bodies dug up on the property in the months that followed. And nothing for the sacks of lye I’d stared at curiously in the dark, which investigators assumed had been used to destroy the others.
Not enough. Too much. I didn’t know anymore.
The box had long since moved from the closet floor and now lived under my bed instead, in the new apartment I’d moved into after I started at the antique store, after I started dating again, after I started doing the ordinary things people do when they are trying to become ordinary.
Forty-seven letters.
The count hadn’t changed.
And Rowan Cross was being released today.
I’d known the date for months. I had circled it on the calendar in red, crossed it out, then written it in again so many times that the paper had worn thin. I’d told myself I wouldn’t come. That there was no reason to come. That the man walking out of those gates was the same man who had stood in my father’s house with a gun in his hand and blood on his conscience, and that I owed him nothing.
But here I was.
My car smelled like leather and coffee, and the black interior carried a thin layer of dust I kept saying I was going to clean but never got around to. The engine was off. I folded my hands in my lap. Yet, I couldn’t take my eyes off the little white ghost hanging from my keys.
It had come back to me, buried in the box of personal effects the detective handed me in the hospital over three weeks after Rowan’s arrest. The same box that contained my purse, the broken photograph of my parents, and my jewelry box.