Page 61
“Fine. Does that mean I get a turn with the questions?”
I lift my chin and jab my bottle in his direction. “Oh no, this is totally non-reciprocal. Besides, I’m nowhere near as interesting.”
“I’m interested,” he says quickly, and I don’t reel in the flash of surprise on my face fast enough. The tips of his ears turn pink. “I mean… Not like – that, or anything.”
“No, of course not,” I brush the non-existent lint off my jeans and the uncomfortable pang of… something, from my gut. Disappointment? “That would be…”
“Yeah,” he says slowly, rubbing his forearm. “Right. Well. How about this, then? I ask, and you call ‘out of bounds’ whenever you want.”
I tear a strip off the bottle label. “That’s very accommodating.”
“This part of you I’ve managed to figure out. You spook easy.”
“I spook easy?”
He draws in his knees and scratches at something on in pants. “You do. I only have my own assumptions on why, obviously. So this might be completely off base. But you’re a walking dichotomy.”
“Using your big boy words, Theo. Look at you go.”
He nudges me. “See – that’s exactly what I’m talking about. You’re funny. You’ve got a sharp tongue and you’re not timid about going head-to-head with people, least of all me, which… not to sound full of myself or anything, but very few people actually have the guts to do that. You aren’t shy by any stretch… and then suddenly you are.”
I shift uncomfortably. “I’m private, I guess.”
He shakes his head. “No, I don’t think you are. Not naturally, at least. I can see the gears shift sometimes, in your head. Like you’re biting your tongue, finding reasons to shut down. The only time I’ve ever seen you really let yourself be is when we argue. I think you get a real kick out of bickering with me.”
I smile wryly. “Why do you think I agreed to the forty percent rule?”
I realize I’ve completely shredded the label off my water bottle. I bundle it up in my fist. He holds out his hand for the balled-up paper and tosses it into the waste bin under the counter.
“So, did I get it right?”
I knew I’d become closed off after my family imploded. It was completely premeditated, designed to protect myself from further loss. But I don’t think I ever realized I’d become bad enough for people to notice.
I let my head loll against the counter. “Bickering is easy. Most of all with people I don’t get along with. Didn’t get along with,” I amend as an afterthought.
“Sure,” he shrugs. “It’s low stakes. Nothing to lose.”
I nod. “So I guess you did get it right. I’ve been burned pretty badly by people who should have been the last to burn me. And I’m not really looking for a repeat. If that means being a little closed off, so be it.”
I feel Theo’s eyes on me even though I stare fixedly at the oven.
“Who burned you?”
His voice is soft, completely tentative and if I’m interpreting it right, it’s completely devoid of expectation. Like he knows he’s not getting an answer, but wants me to know he’s interested. That the way I feel is meaningful enough to probe. But we’re approaching dangerous territory now. And I’m not willing to share that part of me. Not here, not with him. The playfulness that’s developed between us is just too fresh.
“Out of bounds,” he supplies after a second. It’s a statement and not a question, and the look he gives me is entirely sympathetic.
“Out of bounds,” I nod, eyes drifting back to the oven, and I take in the smell and bubbling sounds of cooking eggs. “Oh, fuck!”
Theo jumps beside me. “What just happened?”
I shuffle to the oven on my knees and peer inside. “The frittata! I forgot to season it.” I hear a low laugh behind me. “You knew! Why didn’t you say anything?”
He fights off a smile. “You told me to trust the process.”
I give him a look of mock-outrage. “This is sabotage! Absolutely rotten sportsmanship. You wanted me to fail –”
“Never.”