AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The No-Judgment Zone

Page 37

by Ellie K. Wilde

Jenna turns with her back a little stiff, giving my hesitation a small, pinched smile. “It’s okay, Finn, we don’t have to. It was just an idea.”

She clasps an oven mitt tightly between her hands. She looks… What is that look, exactly?

It’s as though someone’s stuffed embarrassment, resignation, and a dash of hurt into a mason jar, and shook it up until it emulsified into this heavy, self-conscious look that’s painful to see. It’s so damn close to the look I caught on her last night, after we called off the flirting. How hard she was taking the rejection. I couldn’t stomach it then, and I sure as hell can’t now.

“You just dangled two of my favorite things in the world in front of me,” I tell her. “Documentaries and you in those spandex shorts. That’ll teach me for making plans.”

Her body expels its tension, and her eyes go back to the way they should always be—bright and playful. “Tomorrow then?”

“Hell, yeah.”

With a nod and an even bigger smile, she turns to lift her dish out of the oven. “Where are you going?”

“I…” I know I can’t muster up the right kind of enthusiasm to say that I’m visiting my dad, and I don’t want her to ask about him again. If I can’t fuck my way into her good graces, the least I can do is keep things light and fun enough to tempt her into a real friendship.

Good Time Finn. People love him.

She gives me a curious look over her shoulder. “Oh. You’re going on a date.”

“What? What makes you say that?”

“You aren’t wearing your glasses tonight.” It’s true that I’ve worn them around more often in the past week and a half. Had no idea she noticed. “And I’ve been wondering since… Well, I noticed you haven’t been going out lately. I figured it was only a matter of time. Where are you taking her?” she asks nonchalantly, but she shoves things around in a drawer with enough force to seem upset.

“Hang on a minute,” I say, rounding the counter. “Jenna—”

She turns, knife and fork in hand, and there’s nothing like the intense relief I feel at seeing the lack of pink in her eyes. She pauses when she sees my expression. “What?”

“I… Are you alright?”

Her gaze drifts slowly to the side. “What do you mean?”

She isn’t upset.

Of course, she isn’t. She’s made it clear she can handle casual, and we agreed on platonic, anyway. This is what I wanted. To distance myself from the trap of romantic emotion. So… why does this feel like pulling a soufflé out of the oven, only to watch it collapse?

“Finn?” she prompts me.

“Nothing. Forget about it,” I say, clearing my throat. “You’re going for a run, you said?”

“Yup, just a short one. Don’t let me keep you.” She gathers up her hair and ties it on top of her head. “I’ll even save you a veggie enchilada. A post-hook up snack to regain your strength.”

She thinks I’m going out to fuck another girl and she’s teasing me about it. She doesn’t care, and it’s a soggy, droopy mess of a soufflé.

“Actually,” I say, shoving the hair off my face. “That documentary sounds good.”

“We can watch when you get back?” she asks, oblivious to the mindfuck tearing through my system. “I’ll wait up for you if you ask nicely. Just promise me you’ll shower first.”

This is what I wanted. This is what I wanted—

“Finn?”

“No.” I clear my throat again. I really need to stop doing that. “Don’t worry about it. You can watch it if you want. I’ll catch up on it later.”

“Okay…” She shrugs. “Have fun.”

This is what I wanted—

I zombie-walk my way to the front door.