AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Twelve Days of You

Page 43

by Ellie K. Wilde

I frown at the napkin. I could’ve sworn he’d had sandwiches on the menu when Jas and I had wandered in eight months ago. In fact, I’d eyed a grilled cheese that reminded me of Dad’s.

Had West removed them from his menu after⁠—

“How long have you two known each other?” Debbie asks now, recalling our attention.

West stuffs nearly an entire meatball into his mouth, trusting me to answer for us both. A critical mistake on his part.

“We go way back to high school. West lived next door, and I was the girl he fell madly in love with at first sight.”

I pass West his glass of wine when he chokes on the meatball.

“How sweet!” Debbie chimes. Beside her, Patty looks like she’s just swallowed a rotting fish.

“I’m only kidding,” I say. “We were friends who lost touch until recently. Somehow, we found ourselves with businesses across the street from each other. A whole thousand miles from home.”

Mira gives a sage nod. “I give it a year before you’re pregnant.”

It’s my turn to choke on a meatball. West smirks, handing me my wine.

“We aren’t dating,” I clarify. “I’m . . .” Madly in crush with his brother.

“Give it time,” Mira says.

“The world works in mysterious ways,” Debbie adds. “Haven’t you wondered how it’s possible you ended up together again after all that time?”

“Sometimes,” I say. I glance at West, who’s quietly watching me. “My business partner and I were denied lease after lease before we finally got the storefront we did. And there he was.”

Softness ripples over West’s features. “I couldn’t believe it,” he says, voice dropped to a murmur. His deep brown eyes seem to search mine for something. “It’s poetic in a way. You were always the girl next door.”

“Poetic,” I echo quietly. I feel an odd urge to lean closer, with twisty feelings in my stomach that I shouldn’t be having for a man who’s all but delivering me to his brother. “How very sentimental of you, Weston.”

After a round of incredible tiramisus, West sneaks away and reappears on the bus with another one of his maps. For the hour that follows, we rehearse more carols while Sir Harry makes an unwilling nest of West’s lap.

This time, when we arrive in Halesberry—a town known for its over-the-top Christmas light installation that spans half its square mileage—West and I make it through an entire rendition of “Deck the Halls” before breaking character. It’s me who cracks first again. But in my defence, no one with a modicum of a sense of humor could withstand watching West McAllen scowl his way through a joyful carol, the words growling out of him as he promises me painful retribution with his eyes.

Patty sidles up to me just before we disband for the night at an inn in town. She crosses her arms over her red peacoat, quiet as we watch West haul bags from the bus’s undercarriage.

Bless the fit of his jeans. Truly.

“You’re really not together?” she asks.

“We’re really not together.”

She contemplates that. “You stare at him a lot for someone who isn’t interested.”

Who said I’m not interested? The thought crystalizes quickly.

Too quickly for someone traveling home to make a move on his brother.

Minutes later, I’m freshly showered and sitting alone in a room barely bigger than its queen-size bed, staring down at Mason’s text from this morning.

BLAIR: Mason, a little bird told me I’ll see you at the Christmas Eve party. Save me a dance?

MASON: Bee! Can’t wait to see you! Just scored an invite to the wedding, too.

It’s the most simple, straightforward text. Exactly as upbeat and friendly as he’s always texted me, despite my earlier (failed) attempt at flirting.

I’ve typed out no less than ten replies, none of them sounding right.