Page 71
Sam Carter looks just how I remember him. Sort of.
He steps out onto the front porch of his gorgeously restored Victorian in a pair of paint-stained shorts despite the cold. Pale blue eyes dripping quiet humor, with a few extra lines at the outer corners. His hair is longer than he used to wear it, a dark blond that’s held off his face with a hair tie in a tiny half bun.
There’s something so comforting in that—he’s older, a father now, but he’s still a little bit him. Sam Carter who used to work in his parents’ mechanic shop on the weekends. Who’d hang out in the parking lot during breaks in school, tinkering with his classmates’ wonky car engines for a bit of extra pocket money, meaning he always smelled a little like engine grease and his clothes were always a little stained.
“Sam, hi.” I step forward, arms out. “Thanks for letting me crash dinner. It’s nice to see you again.”
“You too, Balinsky.” He chuckles into our quick one-armed hug. “Blair, I mean. How you been?”
“Oh, you know . . .” I’m about to shut down my business and get evicted from my apartment. “I’m surviving. You?”
“Surviving.” He grins, then nods at West before they connect for a handshake/bro-hug combo.
When they disengage, Sam’s amused gaze bounces between me and West. Admittedly, we’re standing with an unnatural number of feet between us.
He points at us. “What’s happening here?”
Excellent question, Sam.
Our drive from Newark felt like turning back time to our first day on the road. Trying to hold conversation with a brick wall. Except that the brick wall had almost kissed me in that hotel room. Had touched himself thinking of me just seconds before that. Only to promptly deposit me into the friendzone.
What had I done? Said? Had he finally remembered the trauma of washing vomit out of my hair?
“You gonna make us beg to come inside? It’s freezing,” West says to Sam.
“Freezing,” Sam echoes mildly. “Is it the weather? Or whatever’s going on between you two?”
Sam Carter and the brain-to-mouth filter that’s just as nonexistent as it’d been back in the day. Gotta love it.
“Tell me: How should I introduce you to Sadie and Jules?” he persists.
Something silently passes between the two men. I catch West giving Sam the barest shake of his head, and I can’t help feeling like I failed some kind of test.
“Old friends,” West answers out loud.
“Fuck’s sake.” Sam shakes his head like we’ve both failed a test. Then he nudges open the front door. “Go on inside. I’ll get your things out of the car.”
“It sounds like you caught quite the bug the last few days.”
Sadie reaches over the kitchen island to fill my wineglass. Sam’s wife is a startling kind of stunning—the kind of bright smile, deep dimples, and glossy raven hair that draws the eye no matter what you’re focused on. She’s curvy, fills out her athleisure in a way I so covet. Moves around her gorgeously remodeled kitchen, with its oak cabinets and dark accents, prepping our dinner almost like she’s floating. Or dancing. Dancing on a cloud.
“It was a horror show,” I say, sliding my wine closer. Instead of sipping it, I reach for a cracker on the cheese board laid out on the island. “So glad the news has traveled.”
“Nice to have West around to help, though. Wasn’t it?”
Sadie bends to check on whatever’s in the oven, and I take the opportunity to study her more closely. She’s beautiful, yes. But there’s something else about her. An intangible quality I recognize from Holly, too. I’m positive Sadie steals the show in whichever room she finds herself. She’s exactly the kind of woman that younger me had hoped to become.
“Nice for me, not so much for West,” I tell her, crunching on my cracker. “Tell me something, Sadie. How long into your relationship with Sam did you let him watch you throw up?”
She chuckles, leaning back against the counter. “Well, we met at an underaged party in college where I got my first and last taste of tequila. We flirted, kissed after an especially victorious round of flip cup, and he was holding my hair over a toilet bowl by the end of the night.”
I laugh. “Okay, you kind of killed my point.”
“We’ve stumbled upon a much more interesting one, I’d say.” Sadie grins. “You’re comparing you and West to me and Sam, a married couple with a kid?”
I take a small sip of my wine in hopes of covering my sudden flush, grimacing at the tartness on its way down my throat. Try as I might, I’ve never been a wine girl.
Sadie catches it. “Wine not doing it for you?”