AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

On a Breakaway

Page 24

by Lexi Buchanan

Just then, Dover notices my distress. “Hey, what’s going on?” He pulls me back to the present, reminding me that I’m not alone, even as my emotions threaten to overwhelm me.

“I thought he was staying with me,” I say, my voice tinged with confusion and a hint of disappointment, as I try to make sense of the situation.

He frowns, his brows knitting together in concern. “You said you weren’t sure about him,” he reminds me, his tone gentle but firm, as if trying to help me remember my own feelings from earlier.

“I lied!” I snap, my frustration bubbling over. Then, realizing the truth, I quickly correct myself, my voice softening just a little. “Well, actually, I didn’t lie, but I was wrong. I thought I knew how I felt, but now I realize I was mistaken. I love him.”

“You’ve known him like a day.”

“I’ve known him longer than that.” I notice the look on his face. “Do not say a word.”

He sighs, a note of exasperation in his voice. “I wish you’d make up your mind,” he says, clearly struggling to keep his patience. “I’ll go and catch him,” he adds, already turning as if to follow after the person in question.

Instinctively, I reach out and grab his arm, my grip tight and urgent. “No. Don’t say anything, please. Not a word,” I plead, my eyes searching his for understanding. “Promise me, Dover?” I add, needing his reassurance more than ever.

He looks at me for a moment, then nods solemnly. “I promise,” he says, his voice quiet.

I absolutely cannot allow Dover to reveal my feelings to Nash without my consent. The thought of Nash finding out how I feel before I am ready to tell him myself makes me anxious, especially since I have no idea if he feels the same way about me. While I am certain that Nash cares about me on some level, there are still so many uncertainties between us, not the least of which is the fact that he is younger than I am. This age difference sometimes makes me wonder if he might eventually decide that someone closer to his own age would be a better match for him.

For now, I just want to wait and observe how things develop between us, to see where our relationship might naturally lead without any outside interference. If Nash does come to the realization that he would be happier with someone younger, I know I will be deeply hurt, but even so, I would rather have him make that decision freely than feel pressured to stay with me out of a sense of duty or obligation because Dover got involved.

As these thoughts swirl in my mind, I feel Dover gently press his lips to my forehead in a comforting gesture. The warmth of the kiss soothes me, and slowly, my eyes drift closed, allowing me a brief moment of peace amidst the uncertainty.

* * *

She doesn’t want me. That single, painful thought has been echoing relentlessly in my mind ever since I accidentally overheard the conversation she had with her brother. The words she spoke replay over and over, making it impossible for me to focus on anything else. I know, logically, that we are at different points in our lives—she has her own goals and dreams, and I have mine. Still, I feel that being at different stages shouldn’t automatically mean we can’t try to build something meaningful together. Isn’t it worth the effort to see if we could make it work, despite the obstacles?

Ever since I first saw her—really saw her—my thoughts have been consumed by her. I remember the moment I found her in what has now become her room, completely vulnerable and unguarded. The image of her, so beautiful and unashamed, is burned into my memory. She is stunning, effortlessly so, and there is something about the way she carries herself that draws me in. Beyond her looks, she is incredibly easy to talk to. Our conversations flow naturally, and I find myself opening up to her in ways I haven’t with anyone else. I genuinely enjoy being in her presence, savoring every moment we spend together. The way she looks at me, sometimes with a softness that makes my heart race, sometimes with a spark of mischief, is something I crave. Even the lightest touch from her—her hand brushing against mine, her fingers on my arm—sends shivers down my spine and raises goosebumps on my skin.

Tonight, instead of staying at the hospital as I had originally planned, I found myself coming home. I couldn’t stay there, pretending everything was fine, knowing what I had overheard. I felt compelled to see her, to somehow let her know that I was aware of what she had said, even if I couldn’t bring myself to confront her about it directly. I am upset, there’s no denying that, but I also know that she is hurting right now. She’s vulnerable, and I don’t want to add to her pain by bringing up something that could make things worse for her. So, instead of talking to her, I left. Now, as I drag a weary hand down my face, I can’t help but question my decision. Did I do the right thing by leaving? Should I have stayed, even if it meant putting my own feelings aside for her sake? She’s in pain, and I can’t shake the feeling that I should have been there for her, that I should have stayed by her side when she needed someone the most.

What the hell am I doing?

I head into my room and toss my clothes off. I quickly shower to get rid of the game before I quickly dress in clean clothes. I hesitate a moment before entering Maggie’s room, wondering whether she’ll be upset with me. I’m doing it for her own good, I think, as I do enter. I wonder what she’ll want and start with a long-sleeved t-shirt she favors and a pair of black yoga pants that are on the clean pile of laundry she’d finished before we left earlier. Underwear and sliders. In the bathroom, I just grab the deodorant and a few toiletries I think she might need as well as a clip for her hair.

I hurriedly shove all my belongings into a bag, barely taking the time to check if I’ve forgotten anything and make my way toward the door. Just as I’m about to leave, I’m caught off guard by the sight of Dover standing right outside my condo. He looks utterly exhausted, with dark circles under his eyes and his shoulders slumped as if he’s carrying the weight of the world.

“I need to sit down,” he mutters, not waiting for an invitation as he pushes past me and heads straight for the sofa in my living room. I let out a heavy sigh and close the door behind him, realizing that if Dover has come over this late at night, it must be for something important. There’s a tension in the air that makes my stomach twist with apprehension.

“Is Maggie okay?” I ask, concern lacing my voice as I move to stand near the sofa, watching him sink into the cushions.

He lifts his tired eyes to meet mine, his expression serious. “She thought you were staying with her,” he says, his tone heavy with implication.

Unable to meet his gaze, I look away, my throat tightening as I swallow hard. The guilt and uncertainty are almost overwhelming.

Dover lets out a frustrated groan, rubbing a hand over his face. “You heard what she said,” he continues, his voice softer now. He nods, as if piecing things together for himself. “It makes sense now. Why you suddenly left.”

I take a deep breath, trying to steady myself. “Look. I care about your sister and her baby, okay?” I say, my voice earnest and pleading. “She’s got me all wrong, but I guess that’s something I’m going to have to prove to her. I’m not just going to walk away. I want to make things right, even if it takes time.”

“You’re only twenty, Nash,” he grumbles, his voice tinged with frustration.

“So are you, and it didn’t stop you from suddenly moving in with Levi,” I shoot back, my tone sharper than I intended. I notice a flicker of defensiveness in his eyes, the way his jaw tightens as he processes my words.

“That’s different!” he insists, standing. There’s a note of desperation in his voice, as though he’s trying to convince himself as much as me.

I stand abruptly, feeling the tension coil tighter between us. “I’m not arguing with you about this,” I say, my voice firm and final. I grab my jacket from the back of the chair and sling it over my shoulder. “I’m heading back to the hospital,” I add, making it clear the conversation is over. Without waiting for a response, I stride toward the door, my footsteps echoing in the quiet condo. “Let yourself out,” I call over my shoulder, not bothering to look back.

“Don’t tell Maggie you’ve seen me,” he shouts.