AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Secret Baby For My Brother’s Best Friend

Page 110

by Vivy Skys

Winter. Her name is Winter, and she has my eyes and my hair. She held out a piece of cookie like it was a gift she'd chosen carefully, and I stood there with my hand open, grateful for a piece of sugar the size of a penny because it was the first thing my daughter ever gave me. My daughter, who isn't a baby, who's a little over two years old, old enough to have favorite cookies and opinions and words for people who are supposed to belong to her, and the fact carves years out of my chest.

The timing means Iris knew before I left. It means she knew at the airport, that when I kissed her goodbye and promised I'd visit, she had our child inside her and let me walk through security with nothing but grief and law school and the stupid belief that love could survive distance if both people were brave enough to keep choosing it.

She knew while I called the school to defer. She knew while she told me she needed me. She knew while she sat on my lap, held my face in both hands, and demanded I go become a lawyer because she wouldn't be the reason I gave up my dream.

A bitter laugh tears out of me, and I stop at the corner near the antique store because the sound is ugly enough that a man walking a dog pauses across the street. I look away before he can ask whether I'm all right, because I'm not, and I don't have a socially acceptable version of that answer ready.

I became a lawyer. I graduated, networked, smiled at partners, learned how to survive on bad coffee and worse sleep and the private humiliation of checking my phone after every class like Iris might finally have decided I was worth answering. I stood in rooms full of men who thought ambition meant emptying yourself out for a building with your name nowhere on it, and I told myself I was doing something meaningful because one day I'd have enough to come back with both hands full.

But there was already something waiting for me. Someone. Not a hypothetical future, not the wife and children I pictured in soft, dangerous flashes when I let myself think too long about Iris in my bed, my kitchen; Iris in New York if I'd ever been reckless enough to ask her to come. There was a daughter. There was Winter. It feels like everyone knew.

The rage comes back fast enough that I nearly choke on it. I turn down the side street toward the water because Main Street has too many windows, too many faces, too many people who might know my name and ask questions while I'm trying not to come apart in public. My shoes hit the pavement too hard, my hands keep closing and opening at my sides, sweat slides down my spine, and my breath scrapes in and out of me, shallow and uneven, every inhale tasting like salt and tar and fury.

It feels like everyone knew. Gray knew. My mind catches on Grayson's face in Bud's lot, the way he went careful when Iris came up, the way his clipboard stopped moving when I asked what everyone was hiding. By the time I came home, he knew more than a suspicion. He knew she was mine, because Gray does not miss much, and Winter has my face stamped all over hers.

He held my daughter while I was in New York studying evidence rules and constitutional procedure. He taught her to say Uncle Gray, carried her on his shoulders, watched her grow teeth and take steps and learn words and become a whole little person, and never once picked up the phone to tell me that the woman I loved had a child who looked exactly like me.

My stomach rolls, and I brace one hand against the brick wall of the bait shop and bend forward again, breathing through my teeth.

Kendall knew. There's no way she didn't. She's been living with Iris, sleeping down the hall from Winter, holding her, feeding her, loving her. She's sent me texts from rooms where my daughter must have been playing on the floor, laughed with me on the phone while Winter was probably asleep somewhere nearby, asked me about exams and jobs and Boston and whether I was eating enough, and not once did she say, Dom, Iris had your baby.

My hand slips on the brick, and I pull it back, staring at the red dust smeared across my palm. Kendall was eighteen when this started, still a kid in too many ways even if she'd rather swallow glass than admit it. Iris must have been terrified, Grayson had been grieving, and Maggie had been grieving. Everyone had a reason. Everyone always has a reason.

Reasons do not give me back her first birthday. There must have been cake, ridiculous and beautiful because Iris owns a bakery. Maybe Kendall took pictures. Maybe Sienna sang. Maybe Gray held her up while she stared at the candle. Everyone else got that day. I did not.

I was in New York. What was I doing that day? I stop walking and try to remember, but the dates fold over each other, because law school ate whole months of my life at a time. I can picture myself in my apartment with casebooks spread across the table, a takeout container gone cold by my elbow, my phone facedown because I'd finally learned not to check it every five minutes. Maybe I texted Iris. Maybe I almost did. Maybe I sat there missing a woman who was lighting a candle for our child.

A sound breaks out of me, and I press both hands over my face. Every missed birthday, fever, first step, first word, first fall, every morning Winter became more herself without me there to witness it, lands at once.

I don't know what her voice sounds like when she's sleepy. I don't know whether she likes bedtime stories, whether she's brave with strangers or shy until she warms up, whether she reaches up when she wants to be held, whether she has nightmares. I don't know if she likes pancakes, if she hates peas, if she calls the moon by the wrong name, if she sings Sienna's songs off-key, if she's ever asked why everyone else has a daddy and she doesn't. I don't know my daughter, and that grief hits harder than the rage did.

I stumble the last few steps to the harbor railing and grip the hot metal with both hands. The water below flashes bright under the sun, little hard pieces of light breaking across the surface. Boats rock in their slips. Ropes creak. Somewhere behind me a truck rumbles past, the town going on the way towns do, because the world has always had terrible timing.

I lean over the railing and heave one breath, then another, my throat burning.

I want to drive back to Bud's shop and demand answers from Grayson until his perfect self-control cracks. I want to call Kendall and ask her how she could look at me, how she could let me send her money for books and groceries and flights while she helped raise my child without telling me she existed. I want to turn around and walk straight back into Butter Treats, take Iris by the shoulders, and ask her who gave her the right to decide my dream mattered more than my daughter.

More than any of that, I want to hold Winter. Not the ring, not Iris, not the lie. Winter. I close my eyes, and there she is, solemn and sticky-fingered, calling me big man because she didn't know what else to call me.

Not Daddy.

The railing digs into my palms. Iris did that, and the thought is awful because I still love her, love her enough that even now, with fury eating its way through me, part of me is back in that storage room seeing the fear on her face, seeing the way she waited for me to choose whether Sienna stayed, seeing her keep her mouth shut because I told her not to manage my feelings. She listened. She was trying, even inside the damage she made. That doesn't fix it. Love doesn't fix it. It just makes the hurt less clean.

My phone buzzes in my pocket. I ignore it. It buzzes again, and I pull it out because apparently I've learned nothing about hope and punishment.

Kendall's name lights the screen. I stare at it until the call goes to voicemail. A second later, a text appears.

Kendall: I am so sorry.

My hand tightens around the phone. Another text follows.

Kendall: Please answer when you can. I know you hate me right now but please don't disappear.

I breathe out hard and look toward the harbor, because the unfairest part is that I do not hate her. Iris was scared. Kendall was loyal. Gray kept his promise. Sienna protected her best friend. Maggie held a grieving house together. Everyone made choices, and none of them were me.

My phone buzzes again. This time it's Grayson. I almost laugh, because of course he's calling, probably standing somewhere with his hand in his hair, trying to decide whether to be brother, husband, uncle, mediator, or executioner. Grayson Douglas has never met a crisis he didn't think he could manage if everyone would just stand in the right place and stop bleeding on the floor.

I decline the call, then type with fingers that feel too large for the screen.