AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Secret Baby For My Brother’s Best Friend

Page 14

by Vivy Skys

My brain this morning has been on a loop: What the fuck did I do! Gray is going to kill me. And Dom will never talk to me again.

I keep shoving the heel of my hand into a mound of dough at nine in the morning with a headache that feels like a truck hit me and then reversed to make sure it got me good. Normally, baking helps, but the repetitive motion is only adding to the crazed, pressure-filled feeling in my chest. Fold and turn. Gray will never forgive. Fold and turn. I slept with Dominic Russo. Fold and turn. My brother's best friend. Fold and turn. Just act like it didn’t happen. Fold and turn. Dom was drunk. I was drunk. And adults make hot, sweaty drunken mistakes all the time.

By the time the cinnamon buns are properly kneaded, my hands are itching for another thing to do. It’s only been like seven hours since we fucked. I know because I’ve barely slept, because I’ve been riding the high all morning. Every time I feel the world caving in I think of the overstimulation of my body. How bad I was quaking against Dom’s chest, only wanting more. I’m soaked just thinking about it.

My only saving grace is that I haven't seen Gray today, he’s been missing since the mini Sienna concert. Probably fucking some girl from Brown, or his regular hookup, some girl with the seduction skill of Jessica Rabbit and the personality of paint. This may be the only time I'm grateful that my brother is a grade A whore.

I grab another proofing bowl, dumping the dough into the middle of the table. The sweet juices from the strawberries and the dryness of the raw scone dough dig under my nails as I grind harder than the dough requires. It does nothing to fix anything, but it makes my head throb worse, tequila and cake frosting and the ghost of his mouth against my palm all fighting for space behind my eyes.

I keep waiting for the regret to show up properly, the kind you're supposed to feel the morning after you make a catastrophic decision involving your only brother's best friend, instead what keeps showing up is the memory of his hand at the small of my back and the sound he made over that first bite of cake, low and rough and entirely unplanned, and I have to physically shake my head to get the flour dust moving and my thoughts moving with it.

I've spent seven years building an entire strategy out of not wanting Dominic Russo. It was a full-time unpaid position. I had a whole system: redirect the eye contact, weaponize sarcasm, drink the milkshake from the correct side of the straw. And last night I dismantled the entire operation in the space of one storage room and one very good cake reaction, and now I don't know what to do with my hands, my thoughts, any of it. The scaffolding's gone.

And the worst part, the part I refuse to say even inside my own skull too loudly, is that some sick, traitorous corner of me isn't sorry. That corner keeps replaying the way he said my actual name instead of a nickname, just Iris, low and stripped of all his usual polish, right before he pulled me in closer.

God, I’m such a selfish sister.

I hear the bell over the front door jingle, too early for Sunday customers since the bakery doesn’t open until 11 a.m. today. Only two people in this town have the keys to Butter Treats, Harley and Grayson. I don’t even have to look up to know it’s not Harley.

"You're up early for the walk of shame," I say, not turning around, working the dough like it personally wronged me.

"There was no shame to be walked," Grayson drops onto the stool on the other side of the table.

I suck in a shaky breath, and drop my head down lower, cursing health regulations for my hair being up. I need everything I’ve got not to cower and hide.

I have to act normal, until he says otherwise.

“You know erectile dysfunction is normal,” I jab, grabbing my roller and rolling the dough out.

He lets out a humorless laugh. “You’re so funny, Bubbles.”

“If you weren’t fucking then you missed my infamous chocolate cake for nothing,” I pout, finally looking up at him, but the minute I do my body chills. He's got dark circles under his eyes that could rival mine, and he's picking at a loose thread on his sleeve instead of doing his usual routine, which involves stealing a cookie off the rack and eating it standing in the doorway before I can stop him.

"You look like hell," I tell him, because attack is still, apparently, my best defense, even against my own brother.

"You’re my least favorite sister you know, that?" Unlike normal, there’s no humor in his voice which worries me more. He’s not acting normal. "I need to ask you something, and you can’t get upset.”

My stomach does an immediate, humiliating drop. I run through the last twelve hours at top speed. Nobody saw us go into the kitchen. Nobody saw us come out, we made sure of that, straightened clothes and cooled faces and twenty separate deep breaths in the alley before either of us could be trusted to rejoin a party. I did the math on this already, at length, at two in the morning, staring at my ceiling. He can't know.

“Shoot kid,” I grumble, bending down so I can search for my biscuit cutter and run if the question has anything to do with Dom.

He clears his throat, the rough sound vibrating off of the metal table. “How long is Sienna staying?"

The question lands strange, too flat, like it cost him something to ask it, and for one wild, paranoid second I wonder if this is somehow a trap, a roundabout circling toward the real subject, before I remind myself that Grayson has never once in his life been subtle enough to circle anything. If he suspected me and Dominic, he'd already be standing on my counter shouting about it.

"As long as she wants." I rise to my feet and place the cutter down on the table, wiping my hands on my apron mostly to buy myself a second to read his face properly. "Why?"

"Because I don’t want her here." His jaw tightens, and there's an edge in it I don't recognize.

He almost sounds deeply pained , but that makes zero sense given that Sienna is my friend, not his, not really, not beyond the easy older-sibling rapport they've had since we were kids.

"She's not going anywhere until she wants to, Gray."

"But I just think--"

"What's your problem? We just got her back." I cross my arms, feeling the fight climb up my spine before I've even decided to have it, grateful, honestly, for something to be angry about that isn't the actual thing sitting in my chest like a lit match. "She's allowed to stay here as long as she wants, and I'm not going to put a countdown on it just because you're a fucking recluse."

"Iris, she’s a popstar, and with everything happening with dad," He stands up too fast, the stool scraping the floor, and something flashes across his face too quick for me to name before he shuts it down. "I just don't want to watch you get hurt again when she takes off, because I'm the one who has to deal with you after."