Page 27
A grin of his own stretched across his features, and he subtly offered a fist to pound. “I’d do something more extreme, but I won’t embarrass you by making a scene. At least not until we leave the building.”
Jo laughed and pushed him toward his station. “Go back to where you’re supposed to be.”
He did a small bow, but turned to Jo’s mom before leaving. “I’d love to come to dinner.” He paused halfway down the row, met Jo’s eyes over her parents’ heads, and winked.
“Thank you,” she mouthed when her parents weren’t looking, then braced herself for the flood of questions to follow.
9
Freshman Year - October
“So have you and Grey done it yet?”
Jo stopped pushing the chicken tenders around on her plate and blinked back to the lunch table in front of her. The roar of the surrounding crowd slowly trickled in, building until her ears buzzed with it. She’d been having a hard time staying present all day, like her brain was refusing to participate in this reality. She didn’t even notice her mind wandering or her vision unfocusing until someone drew her back.
Kayleigh stared at her expectantly from across the table. Her mascara was slightly smudged from the rain. Jo shot a quick glance at Miller beside her, but he was thumbing through a book, pointedly not listening.
Jo sighed and gathered her hair into a high ponytail. She and Grey had gotten close to having sex plenty of times—every time she was with him, if she were being honest—but every time, she’d pulled away. It wasn’t that she didn’t want to, exactly. But she didn’t know how to tell him it would be her first time, or if she even should. And she couldn’t shake off this feeling that the moment they did it, everything would change between them.
“Not yet,” she mumbled.
“Isn’t he going on tour, like, tomorrow?” asked Kayleigh. “It’ll be your last chance for a while.”
Jo had been pointedly not thinking about that. They’d be gone on tour for months—she wouldn’t even see him again until next semester. She wasn’t just assuming they’d pick up where they left off—she wasn’t that naïve. But still…
“Just leave her alone,” muttered Miller.
“If the sex talk bothers you, go sit with the boys!” Kayleigh pointed across the room to where Foster and Gatsby were sitting with the other fraternity pledges. It looked like they were piling as many condiments on a plate as possible and chanting until one of them ate a spoonful.
Miller flipped the page. “I’d rather be around people with more than one brain cell, thanks.”
“So are you going to see him tonight?” asked Kayleigh.
Jo nodded. “I’m going over to his place to hang out.”
Kayleigh ooooohed.
“Not like that.” Jo rolled her eyes. “Other people will be there too. It’s like a going-away party.”
Miller brought his hand to his chest. “And we weren’t invited?”
Jo raised her eyebrows. “Do you want to come?”
“Not if you’re going to be banging Grey in the bathroom!” shrilled Kayleigh, loud enough that the table next to them all turned around to look. Jo stared them down until they looked away.
“No, really,” said Jo. “You guys should come. You haven’t really gotten to know Grey yet anyway—we can do a pregame and everything.”
“I’m in,” said Kayleigh. “I’ve been waiting for you to introduce me to his hot band friends.”
“Miller?” Jo kicked him under the table. “Tell me you’ll come.”
He closed his book with an audible thunk. “Fine. But you’ll have to get me really drunk first.”
Grey’s apartment was on the twentieth floor of a high-rise downtown. Despite the hundreds of windows littering the side of the building, Jo had come to recognize exactly which one was his from the street. Today it was full of life, the shades wide open, red lights flashing inside. Car horns blared as their Uber pulled to the side of the street.
Jo stumbled out first and righted her plaid skirt as Kayleigh and Miller climbed out after her. They were both in jeans, making Jo feel a little out of place next to them in her mesh top and high heels, but Grey liked when she wore skirts. And this was the last night she’d see him for months—something she had to force herself to stop thinking about. She teetered a bit on the sidewalk, the vodka hitting her harder than usual since she’d skipped dinner. It hadn’t been intentional. She hadn’t been able to muster an appetite since that conversation at lunch.
The doorman nodded as they headed inside and quietly shuffled toward the elevator, trying not to draw any attention. Judging by the stiff set of Miller’s shoulders and the way Kayleigh was practically holding on to him for dear life as they crossed the lobby, Jo wasn’t the only one affected by the pregame.