Page 66
“Gracie.” Jo clapped her on the shoulders. “You look hot, and it’ll be fun. Miller will take good care of you, I promise. He’s the best date ever.”
Gracie nodded a few too many times.
Jo squeezed her shoulders and nodded toward the door. “Now go. Your car will be downstairs in, like, sixty seconds.”
Gracie bit her lip, her hands wrapping around the tiny black clutch Jo had dug out from the back of her closet. “You’re sure you’ll be okay here?”
“Yes. Now go.” Jo waved her off, and with one final glance in her direction, Gracie headed into the hallway and closed the door behind her.
At first, the silence was startling. The previous hour had been so full of chatter and activity, she’d been too busy and distracted to think about anything else. But now Gracie was gone, and Jo watched through the window as she climbed into the Uber, and the car sped off down the road.
Now it was just her. She’d probably get hell from Miller later on, but for now, she had the night to herself. She hadn’t had much downtime the past few weeks. Maybe a quiet night was exactly what she needed. She could rent a movie and have a glass of wine. Order dinner in. Hell, she could break out the face masks and paint her toenails. Cautiously, she wove her way through the maze of makeup and hair products still littering the carpet and paused in the center of the room, her gaze lingering on a discarded pair of gold hoops sitting on the dresser.
The first Christmas present Miller had given her.
She shook her head and headed to the bathroom to collect everything she needed for the night. Arms full of face masks and nail polish, she plopped herself on the bed to scroll through the TV for a movie. She’d finally settled on an old favorite when her phone buzzed against the blankets. Her heart sank at the sight of Miller’s name, but she didn’t open the text. It was too late now, and even if he was mad, he was too much of a gentleman to be anything but a good date to Gracie tonight. They’d have to talk eventually. But eventually could wait until tomorrow.
She headed to the kitchen and let out a long sigh as she opened the fridge and realized she was out of wine. She opened a few cabinets, checking for any kind of liquid companion for the night, but came up empty-handed.
Well, shit.
A glance out the window confirmed the rain she heard on the roof, but still, she slipped on some shoes, threw a raincoat over her sweats, and headed for the door. Tonight would not be complete without a glass of wine. There was a liquor store just around the corner, and at this point, she really didn’t care who saw her looking like this. If it weren’t raining, she’d probably just walk. Today, though, she ducked her head against the rain and hurried over to her Jeep.
The man behind the counter nodded at her as she stepped inside. A few frat guys lingered over by the beers, but other than that, the store was empty. Jo headed straight for the wine, picking up two boxes—one red, one white. She paused in the aisle and bent over to inspect a nearby bottle that caught her eye. There was something familiar about it, though it was way out of her price range, so she knew she’d never bought it for herself. It had a sticker next to it on the shelf, advertising that it was local.
She straightened again, the pieces clicking in her head. It was the wine her parents had ordered at dinner the other night with Miller.
The dinner Miller had still gone to despite everything that had happened that day.
She looked down at the boxes of wine in her hands. She was being a coward. She was being a coward and a bad friend.
“Fuck,” she muttered, set the boxes back on the shelf, and turned to leave. The sight of the person coming through the door froze her in place. The bell chimed overhead as the girl stepped into the shop, her blonde hair damp from the rain. She lifted her head and spotted Jo before Jo had the chance to react.
“Hey.” Kayleigh walked toward her, her rain boots squeaking with each step. “I’m actually so glad I ran into you.”
Jo stared at her, momentarily lost for words. Kayleigh had never been outwardly hostile toward her, but their interactions usually consisted of them avoiding eye contact, pretending they hadn’t seen each other, and carrying about their business. Kayleigh was definitely looking at her now, eyes wide, teeth deep in her lower lip.
Jo shifted beneath the weight of her stare. “I—oh? Why?”
“I wanted to apologize,” she said in a rush, the words practically tripping over each other. She dropped her gaze at the word apologize, her voice lowering as she added, “I feel so bad.”
Jo blinked, really confused now. She’d stopped waiting for an apology from Kayleigh years ago, but whatever this was about—whatever was making Kayleigh so fidgety and flushed—it was something more than just freshman year. Jo cleared her throat. “For what?”
Kayleigh shifted her weight and glanced at the slushy machines in the back corner, her gaze sweeping the rest of the store before coming back around to Jo, as if searching for someone to help her. “I didn’t mean to tell him…it just sort of came out. He was asking about you—and sometimes he just talks so much and asks so many questions, and I just wanted him to stop. I didn’t even think. I’m sorry.”
“Kayleigh, I have no idea what you’re talking about.”
She covered her face with her hands, her next words coming out muffled. “I accidentally told Jordan about freshman year…with Grey and everything. I really didn’t mean to, I swear.”
Jo stared at her, her entire body tensing at just the sound of his name. “You’re the one who told Jordan.”
Kayleigh nodded, hands still firmly pressed to her face.
Jo shook her head, trying to clear it. “I didn’t even know that you…” she trailed off, her throat tightening too much to speak.
Kayleigh finally dropped her hands and fidgeted with the zipper on her jacket. “I saw the tests in the bathroom trash.”
For a moment, neither of them spoke. Jo didn’t feel anything at the revelation, not at first. The anger, however, came shortly after.