AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Tell Me It’s Wrong

Page 110

by Katie Wismer

I force a smile onto my face as I reach the kitchen, where everyone else is already gathered around the counter. In the center waits a three-tiered cake that appears to be covered in every type of chocolate imaginable.

Fletcher smiles, takes my hand, and pulls me in front of it as the group descends into the obligatory Happy Birthday song. Casey squeezes in on my other side, standing on his tiptoes to see the cake.

“Make a wish! Make a wish!” he urges as everyone finishes the song and cheers.

I stare at the flames flickering on the candles for a moment. They cast a warm glow over everyone’s faces—faces that are smiling at me. No judgment, no impatience, no apathy. And I suppose if I have anything to wish for, it’s just more of this.

I close my eyes and blow out the candles, and the room erupts in another round of applause.

“Happy Birthday, Mom!” Casey throws his arms around my middle and hugs me as tightly as he can.

I squeeze him back. “You want to help me cut the cake?”

“Oh, I’ll do that!” Gracie steps in, giant knife in hand, and Leo spreads the plates out along the counter.

Fletcher presses a kiss to my temple. “Happy Birthday.”

He gives me a soft smile, but I don’t miss the tension in his brow, or the way his eyes keep flickering toward the stairs.

I squeeze his arm. “You can go get Jacks. It’s okay.”

He frowns and looks between me and the stairs again. “You’re sure?”

I nod. “Just let me know when you two make it home okay. And thank you for all of this, Fletch. Really.”

“I’ll call you later, all right?”

“You’re leaving?” Casey blinks up at him with puppy dog eyes.

“Yeah, bud. I gotta go.” He crouches down to give Casey a hug.

“We’ll save a piece of cake for you,” Casey promises.

Fletcher’s smile turns crooked as he rises to his feet and ruffles Casey’s hair. “I’ll hold you to that.”

“For the birthday girl.” Gracie presents me with a very generous slice, and Casey tugs on my hand to lead me to the table. By the time we’re situated, Fletcher is already gone.

Chapter Thirty-Eight

FLETCHER

We spend the first half of the drive in utter silence. Jacks’s eyes are closed, and she has her head leaned against the window, but I know she’s not asleep. My knuckles ache from how tightly my hands are wrapped around the steering wheel, but I force myself to think through what I’m going to say. Letting my anger win out here won’t help.

Because the fact of the matter is, I’m not her dad, and she’s not wrong. I wasn’t a saint at eighteen. And under different circumstances, I might not have been as bothered. But Christine deserved for this night to be perfect, or at the very least, not cut short like this. Not to mention I’d been hoping to spend more time with her after the party was over. And Jacks knew that.

I can’t help but feel like this was intentional. But maybe it wasn’t.

We’re a few minutes to the house when I finally manage to calmly ask, “Do you want to explain to me what happened tonight?”

“Not really,” she mumbles.

“It was a rhetorical question.”

“Then you didn’t need an answer.”

I let out a short breath through my nose. “Explain what the hell happened, Jacks.”

“Okay, party police. So I had a few drinks. Calm down.”