AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Tell Me It’s Wrong

Page 44

by Katie Wismer

The lines around his eyes soften, and his thumb runs across my cheek. “I want you in whatever way I can have you. If you need to hide me to make that happen, I wouldn’t take it personally. Just let me be here. Let me be here for you.”

I squeeze my eyes closed. “Fletcher⁠—”

“And outside of this house, I’ll act however you want me to. Pretend I don’t know you, if that’s what you need.”

My heart drops. “You deserve better than that.” I lower his hands from my face and pull in a deep breath as I lean my head against the wall. How the hell did we end up here?

“Tell me you don’t think about me,” he says. “Tell me you don’t think about that night. Because I can’t stop thinking about it. All I do these days is think about you.”

I don’t say anything—I can’t. Because of course I’ve thought about it. No matter how hard I’ve tried, I haven’t been able to stop. I haven’t had a moment of peace since it happened. Even when I’m not actively thinking about it, I can feel it somewhere deep down, the shift.

I’d thought maybe it was because it had been so long. Julian and my sex life deteriorated long before the marriage. The last time I had a one-night stand would’ve been over ten years ago.

And it definitely hadn’t gone the same way.

But if it wasn’t about that, if it wasn’t just the sex…I haven’t let myself think about that. I can’t.

“You’re too young for me, Fletcher,” I whisper.

“See, I’m not buying that.”

“You are a decade younger than me. That’s a big deal.”

He doesn’t respond at first, and when I look to him, a small, playful smile tugs at the corners of his mouth.

“Don’t men have shorter life expectancies on average? I think it’s six years. And you’re nine years older. So that pretty much evens us out. That leaves a three-year gap, if you’re being stingy. And three years is perfectly acceptable.”

I fight the urge to smile. He’s clearly thought about this before. “Your mental gymnastics are truly impressive.” Quietly, I add, “People would think I’m taking advantage of you.”

“If I was eighteen, I could see that. But I’m not some naive kid. But if you see me that way, then yeah, I’d say we have a problem.”

“Of course I don’t see you that way.”

“So that’s it then? You’re just worried about what other people would think?”

“No.” It’s not nearly as simple as that, but I don’t know how else to explain. “You know that I was twenty-three when I met Julian?”

Granted, that age difference was a lot more than nine years. At the time, I thought I knew exactly what I was getting into. Thought I knew what I wanted. Thought the playing field was even. And as much as I don’t want to, when I look at Fletcher, a part of me can’t help but see a past version of myself.

Fletcher is quiet for what feels like a very long time, his expression unreadable, but his eyes are locked on my face like he’s searching for something.

Finally, he says, “You are nothing like him. And this is nothing like that. This is something. You can’t tell me it’s not.”

He’s so close I can smell his cologne, feel the heat radiating from his skin.

“This might come across as insensitive, but things are bad already, aren’t they? People with their stupid fucking gossip—would it be so much worse if you add me to it? The way I see it, give them something to talk about. You’re giving them too much power, Chris. And they don’t matter.”

If that’s all there was to it, maybe I would.

“It’s not about…” I shake my head, a tear escaping from the corner of my eye.

“Then what⁠—”

“It’s Casey,” I all but sob.

I know I’m not a perfect mom. I might not even be a good one. But I’ll be damned if I don’t at least try to be better than mine was for me.

And if there’s one thing she never, ever did for me, it was put me first.