AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Tell Me It’s Wrong

Page 50

by Katie Wismer

I roll my head to the side to look at him. “I guess fair’s fair.”

He searches my face, as if debating his next words. But then something shifts behind his eyes, like he decided against whatever it was. Instead, he says, “I hear you throw a hell of a party. So when do I get to see you in action?”

I smirk. “Well, I actually am helping Gracie with something for next weekend. Do you want to come?”

“Would that…be okay?”

“I don’t mean with me, obviously,” I say quickly. “It’s for a friend of hers who’s from out of town, and Gracie wants her to get to know some people around here. A lot of people you know will be there—like Liam and Asher, and Gracie’s brother. It’s a pretty open guest list.”

His eyes search mine. “But you’ll be there?”

I nod.

His smile softens. “Then absolutely.”

Hours pass like minutes as we drink and talk and soak in the last moments of the day. The sun sets, and Fletcher has to replace the propane tank to keep the fire going, but still, we don’t go inside. We break out a second bottle of wine, and the later it gets, the closer I inch toward him on the couch without really meaning to. We add a blanket into the mix at some point, and he keeps my legs draped over his lap, his hands never breaking contact with me in one way or another—resting on my knee, stroking the inside of my ankle, or my shoulder, or linking with my own.

And every once in a while, he’ll get this look on his face, like he’s physically holding himself back from saying something, but then he’ll shift the conversation to something equally light—what movies are my and Casey’s favorites, what kind of music I listen to.

Once I’m several glasses of wine in, I say, “Just ask me whatever it is, Fletch.”

He frowns and sips his drink. “Don’t know what you mean.”

I nudge him in the ribs, and he rolls his head toward me, his lips pressed together in a sheepish smile. “You don’t have to answer it.”

I nod.

“I…I guess I just wondered what led you here. I know you left home at sixteen, and you met your ex when you were around my age. So, what happened in between? That’s a good six, seven years. And how the hell did you end up with a guy like that? Because you seem like the kind of person who wouldn’t put up with his shit for even a second, let alone eight years.”

My stomach dips a little, the same way it always does when memories from that time threaten to resurface. I blow out the air in my cheeks. To put it simply: a lot. A lot happened in those years.

And not much of it was good.

“I am now. I didn’t used to be. I didn’t used to be…a good person, Fletcher.”

“I don’t believe that for a second.”

I don’t meet his eyes. I can’t.

“I know what people around here say about me. That I married him for his money. And they’re not wrong,” I whisper. “They’re not wrong. But that also wasn’t all it was.”

I swallow hard and squint at the fire. The wine has me feeling barely in my body, and it loosens my tongue in a way I’ll probably hate myself for in the morning. Fletcher strokes his thumb along my knee and waits.

“Things were…things were bad growing up. I never had clean clothes. Half of my mom’s boyfriends liked looking at me more than her. Instead of helping me, it made her angry and bitter and jealous. I actually preferred the times we didn’t have a roof over our heads, because at least then I was free of them. I kept thinking if I could just get out of West Virginia, then things would work out somehow. So I left. I didn’t have a car—I didn’t even have a bank account. But I had enough to buy a bus ticket that would get me to Richmond.”

Fletcher shifts a little closer to me, and I startle out of whatever trance I’d been in as he brushes my hair behind my ear. Despite the heavy look in his eyes, it’s not the same judgment and disgust I’ve grown used to seeing these past few months. “So you just went? All by yourself?”

I nod.

“What did you do when you got there?”

I shrug. Everything I owned could fit into a backpack and a duffel bag. The day I stepped off that bus…first, there was a moment of pure, giddy joy. I’d never seen a city that big, never been that far from home. And I’d done it. I’d done it.

But then reality came crashing in. And the icy, heavy fear that flooded my veins. I thought I’d felt fear before. Lived with it day in and day out.

But this chapter of my life was something different entirely. Not knowing where I’d sleep, when I’d eat next—that was nothing new. But doing it alone was.

I clear my throat, but the tightness there remains. “I got lucky. Really lucky. My plan was to find a job, maybe waiting tables. I’d done some of that back home. I didn’t have enough money for a place to stay, but I could afford this cheap gym membership, so at least I had access to their showers. And I could put my things in their locker rooms during the day as long as I went back for them before they closed.