Page 75
She opens her mouth and shuts it again.
"I've hinted," she says finally. "A lot."
"Hints don't count," I tell her.
"Not with a man like Derek. He fights fires, Paige. He doesn't pick up on hints. He waits for somebody to yell 'go.'"
Tessa laughs into her glass. Paige glares at both of us, and then her mouth twitches.
"You think I should just say it," she says.
"I think you should sit him down and say, 'I want to marry you, and I need to know if you want the same thing,'" I say.
"Then you listen to what he says. If you don't ask, you'll never know. You'll spend another year reading every shrug like it's an answer."
I hear my own voice as I say it, and something twists low in my stomach. I spent three years reading Cole's shrugs. I explained every one of them to myself. Somebody should have told me this in a café three years ago.
"You're worth a straight answer," I tell her.
"You're worth more than a man who makes you guess."
Paige looks at me for a long moment. Her eyes fill, and she blinks it back hard.
"When did you get so wise?" she asks.
"I had a bad October," I tell her.
She laughs, and the tears spill over anyway. She wipes them with her napkin and squeezes my hand hard before she lets go.
Our food comes. Paige ordered for all three of us: the croque madame, the steak tartare, and a plate of roasted carrots nobody touches. For a while we just eat. Paige talks about the bridesmaid dresses, which were the color of canned salmon.
Tessa says very little. I feel her watching me while I cut my sandwich. When I reach for the bread basket, my sweater sleeve rides up my wrist.
There's a faint pink line across the inside of my wrist. It's thin and smooth, the width of a man's silk tie. I haven't noticed it until now. Tessa's eyes go straight to it. They stay there a beat too long, and then they come up to mine.
I pull my sleeve down over my hand. Paige is busy with the tartare and doesn't see.
"How was the work trip?" Tessa asks mildly.
"Long," I say.
She nods slowly. She picks up her glass and takes a sip, and she doesn't look away from me.
The waiter clears the plates and brings three coffees. Paige has moved on to the best man's toast, which apparently included a slideshow.
"He had a photo of Derek's brother at his prom," she says, "with a mullet. A real one, Harper. Business in the front—"
I'm only half listening. I reach for my coffee and lift the cup by its little handle, and the white china catches the candlelight.
I see it.
I see the kitchen in Sag Harbor at 9:15 this morning, bright with sun off the bay. I see two cups sitting side by side on the counter beside the coffee machine, exactly where I set them down. One of them is his. The other one has a soft print of rose-colored lipstick on the rim.
I left it there. I swept a whole nightstand into my bag and ran through a hedge barefoot, and I left a cup with my mouth on it in the middle of his kitchen.
My hand stops halfway to my lips.
Cole walked into that kitchen. He always goes to the kitchen first. He opens the refrigerator in every house he walks into, like he's checking that it's still his. He would have been standing three feet from that counter.