Page 5
“How could I forget, mystery girl?” Once again, he stares at me with so much intense focus that I sink further into my seat. “What about the distraction and drowning of sorrows?”
“Also El’s job,” Bridget quips, and I look sharply at her, but she only quirks an eyebrow and smirks at me.
Mercifully, the waitress appears at that moment, saving me from discussing my job further. In my experience, guys aren’t really all that excited to learn I referee hockey for a living, especially in settings like this. A date once told me that it made him think of me as being less feminine once he learned, and he didn’t see me the same anymore.
“What can I get y’all?” she asks.
“More vodka sodas!” Bridget cheers.
“Noooo,” I groan. “Water for me. I’m going to hate myself tomorrow if I drink anymore.”
“Boooo,” Bridget jeers, Logan chuckling at her side. He doesn’t talk much, but he sure seems obsessed with her. The perfect guy for Bridget, really.
“Water for all of us, I think,” Andy says responsibly, and I give him a grateful look.
“Boooo,” Logan now echoes, and Bridget breaks out into uncontrollable giggles. The poor waitress looks back and forth between the two couples, unsure what to do.
“Water, and a reminder that I’m the one paying the tab on that massive shindig over there,” Andy says casually as he nods in the direction of his VIP area, which has descended into a drunken and wild party. Something about his quiet confidence, with just a tinge of earned arrogance, makes my body lean closer to his.
The waitress grins. “Water it is, then.”
While she’s gone, Bridget and Andy discuss something that I don’t pay attention to, my mind whirling to figure out what he could do that makes him fit and gives him the kind of money needed to bankroll a dozen of his friends and dozens more of the women they met in a private room at Kansas City’s most elite and exclusive club.
“Where’d you go?” Andy whispers in my ear, and I jerk, knocking my head into his nose hard.
Bridget snorts, and Logan smirks. “Oh my god. I’m so sorry,” I apologize. “I was zoning out and you scared me.”
“All good. I’ve had a lot worse.”
“That’s an understatement,” Logan adds.
“Drink your water and let’s go dance more,” Andy says with a nod at the glass in front of me that I have no memory of receiving.
I chug the water, sighing in relief when I finish it. Andy nudges his in front of me, and I chug that too. Then he stands and offers me his hand, leading me back to the dance floor.
We spend the rest of the night together, alternating between dancing, chatting, and making out. Bridget and Logan are with us sometimes, disappearing frequently to do god-knows what. When the DJ stops the music and dim lights wink on, I’m shocked to find it’s already two in the morning. Bridget appears at my side, lipstick smudged and a pink-faced Logan at her side. Andy only shakes his head with elder brother energy when he sees Logan, murmuring that he better drink some water or tomorrow is going to be rough, whatever that means.
Bridget gives Logan a long hug while I stand there awkwardly with my mystery guy. I want to ask for his number. I want him to ask to see me again, but we both said this was one night only.
“So—”
“Listen, El—”
The words are uttered at the same time. “You first,” he finally says with a smile.
“I was just going to say goodnight,” I lie. He stares at me, looking for something. My eyes dart away under his scrutiny.
“Good night, El,” he says, wrapping me in a hug that makes my skin tingle. “Good luck with the celebratory, sorrowful, distraction-needing job.” When he pulls away, placing his hands in the pockets of his tailored jeans, I swear I see disappointment in his eyes. I open my mouth to say something—anything— maybe a witty remark, or blurt out all the things I should keep to myself.
Bridget loops her arm through mine, marching us away. “Au revoir,” she sings, waving her free arm in farewell. Andy’s gaze makes my neck prickle as we exit the club, and I turn right before we step through the door to the street to find him still standing there, hands in his pockets, staring at me.
In the Uber ride home, Bridget grills me with questions, completely unaffected by all the liquor she consumed. Damn her and her incredible metabolism.
I deflect, too disappointed that I don’t have a way to meet him again to really gush with her.
“I cannot believe you made out at a club with a twenty-two-year-old,” I say to nudge the conversation away from Andy.
“I did more than just make out with him,” she whispers conspiratorially.