AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Hard No

Page 89

by Lilian Monroe

Hadn’t I?

As if a forcefield was drawing me toward it, I found myself in front of my own laptop, across from Jack. Now that I knew what I was looking for, it was laughably easy to find out what my mother had been up to these past thirty years. “She married Tony Costa Sr. twenty-six years ago. That would have been…” I frowned. “Six months after the divorce with Dad was finalized.”

My brothers were silent. Bennett finished his pepperoni stick and poured himself a drink, his back to the rest of us. I could see the tension in his shoulders even though I couldn’t see his expression. He was the youngest, and I knew he didn’t remember much about Mom being around. But we were all affected by it. Gideon leaned against my kitchen counter with his arms crossed. Jack slid a finger along his jaw, a frown drawing his brows together.

I continued: “They’re still married, even though he’s in custody awaiting trial. They have—had—two kids. Tony Jr. and Enzo.”

“Enzo’s our half-brother,” Gideon said. “So was Tony.”

There was a short silence, followed by Bennett saying, “Weird.”

Jack leaned forward, propping his elbows on the table across from me. “From what was said at family lunch, it sounds like Caroline chose Marswood Harbor on purpose. Some sort of safe zone from the Costa family?”

The three of them looked at me, and I shrugged. “She didn’t fucking tell me about it.”

The words burst out of me, vehement and vicious. I grimaced, hating how exposed I felt.

Hating how much it hurt.

I’d trusted her. After that day, four and a half years ago, I’d made a conscious decision not to dig into her past. I’d hated the fear in her eyes that day, when she’d looked at me like I was her executioner. I’d gone against my nature because…because what?

Because I liked her? Loved her?

I felt like an idiot. She was just like my deadbeat mother. Lying and scheming her way to whatever she wanted. Stealing money from a dead man to start her own business in a small town. Listening to me tell her about my goddamn mommy issues and staying silent about the fact that she knew where Diane—Viola—whateverthefuck her name was—lived the whole time.

Then Gideon said, “Well, I wouldn’t expect her to tell you shit, after what you put her through.”

My chair hit the wall a second after I jumped to my feet. Gideon blinked at me, slow and unworried. “What’s that supposed to mean?” I hissed.

He took a sip of his drink before spreading his hands. “You tormented her for four fucking years, brother.”

“I didn’t torment her.”

“You lorded the fact that you knew her secret every time you walked into her bakery. And don’t try to fucking deny it. I thought you had a hard-on for her the whole time, and maybe you did, but you figured out the thing about Tony, didn’t you? You kept telling me she had baggage and you didn’t trust her, but you knew, didn’t you?”

“Not about this.”

“But you knew she’d had to kill Tony and run. Left everything behind to save her sister.”

I stared at Gideon. “Yeah, but that—I’m not—it’s—” I spluttered, body tense, vibrating with rage and shame and a sick sort of understanding.

He shrugged, looking almost disappointed in me. My big brother. “I wouldn’t trust you either.”

I stared at him, my breaths coming faster.

Yes, Caroline had lied by omission. Yes, I had a right to be angry about that, especially because she’d had ample opportunity to tell me the truth.

But I’d made damn sure she didn’t think she could trust me. Multiple times a week, month after month, year after year.

I’d brought this on myself. The void in my gut turned aching, like a piece of me had been torn out. I leaned my palms against the dining table, staring at the wood grain as I tried to come to terms with my own part in this fucked-up mess of a situation.

Clarity speared through me, and I knew what I had to do. I straightened in a rush and circled the table.

“Where are you going?” Jack asked.

“To the bakery. I need to talk to Caroline.”

But Caroline was gone. And when I went through the back door and found the little slip of paper with my deadbeat mother’s words on it, I saw red.